logo Sign In

Post #1021179

Author
Ronster
Parent topic
Rogue One * Spoilers * Thread
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1021179/action/topic#1021179
Date created
19-Dec-2016, 12:50 PM

Yeah I don’t see any changes to the very end of the story.

Just got back from the second viewing I once again thoroughly enjoyed it and I can’t remember the last time I went to cinema twice to see a film.

I think it’s still a great film, but that’s it for me now until the Blu-ray comes out. Noticed the flaws much more on second viewing.

Personally I think Vader is the worst handled character in the film. Tarkin and Leia are much better. He sounds and looks completely wrong more so than any other character in the film and the shocking part is it’s a man in a suit and James Earl Jones doing the voice so how they screwed that up I’ll never understand it.

But the voice and I imagine the red eyes that are like he’s been swimming in some kind of bong… It’s poor effort and it needs to be fixed. (It’s good at the end though!!!)

The other thing I noticed is the inter-cutting in act 3 is perhaps worse than act 1 as sequences are left dangling while we cut to somewhere else.

But I have to say I still really like it even though it is flawed. There is a better movie in there somewhere so although Gareth Edwards alluded to not going back to do anything with it i.e. no extended cut and so on.

I would really like him to sort something out. Give the man another Star Wars movie!!!