So long as there are no Best Buy identifiers on it. Any chance you still have the sticker that said it's widescreen? That would help solidify your case with Target or even with Best Buy. Either should take it back but Best Buy would put up more of a stink. Their return policy has become so incredibly strict that they don't even take back their own DVDs that are still sealed and labelled with Best Buy tags unless you still have a receipt proving it was purchased within the last 30 days. If it's outside of 30 days, no return whatsoever. So you better hope your parents shop for your Xmas gifts within a few days of Christmas or there's no chance of you being able to make an exchange at Best Buy if they buy you the wrong thing. Policies like this are the reason I'm buying less and less from Best Buy. Circuit City and Target have been getting an increasing amount of my business.