yotsuya said:
TV’s Frink said:
I find it ridiculous that someone would consider Empire a good ending and TFA a cheat, and give reasons like “ESB felt solid” and “Luke needed dialog.”
TESB follows our main characters as they get split up and try to get away from the Empire. Luke goes to train and ends up back with them as they all try to finally get away. The ending gives us our remaining characters safe on a ship in the rebel fleet. Luke and Leia bid Lando and Chewy good luck finding Han and the two take off on a quest. The big story is wrapped up - the rebels are again safe, but they have lost Han. In TFA, the quest was to find Luke… then what. Showing that they found Luke was a weak ending. It’s like if TESB ended with Lando and Chewy landing on Tantooine and learning that Han is on display in Jabba’s palace. The unfinished quest worked better as an ending. Either no Luke or give Luke something interesting to say that makes the scene worth including. What they did didn’t work for me.
TFA follows Rey, and Finn as they become part of events and accept their destinies. That was more important than the quest to find Luke. Finn finds something to fight for that he believes in- The Resistance and real friends (Rey, Poe, Han and Chewie). With Rey, she accepts the call of the Force, accepts that the belonging she desires will not be found by staying on Jakku, and only at the end is she ready to find Luke and begin her path to becoming a Jedi.
That’s why they meet the heroes as they do, they take further steps into the larger galaxy. First Han and Chewie, then Leia and finally Luke. Luke is not the main star of TFA, Rey is.
As for Han and Chewie finding the Falcon, he fucking said they tracked it. Hyperspace in Star Wars works however the plot demands in. Remember the Emperor sensing Anakin in danger and got from Coruscant to Mustafar in time to save his burnt ass? No more reaching than Han arriving so soon after the Falcon’s transmitter started working.