I’ve watched this movie twice in theaters (once in December, once last week in a 2nd run theater). While there was a lot to like - the more down-to-earth and realistic ground combat, the chemistry between the leads, etc. - I didn’t care for it too much. In fact, I fell asleep both times at different points. That might be down to the premise, though; I’m not sure this is a story that I felt needed telling.
Highlights:
-The CGI people look pretty good. We’re not 100% there yet, but the mocap is pretty convincing (or as realistic as, say, modern animatronics).
-K2SO was a more fun HK-47
-Again, I have to commend the main cast’s chemistry. Felicity Jones and Diego Luna had great rapport.
-I felt like a little kid watching Vader kick ass at the end. What I was most apprehensive about ended up being what I enjoyed the most. Whoever was in the suit did his homework, that felt like Prowse lugging about like in ESB! And it got me both times, not just the first.
Bothersome points:
-I didn’t really care for most of the scenes on Yavin IV. Something didn’t feel right to me seeing there again in this context. And I’m not a continuity nut, so it wasn’t just that I was expecting Dantooine instead.
-Saw Gerrera felt forced. Everything to do with him lacked urgency and felt like a subplot, even though Jyn needed to find him to hear about the design flaw in the Death Star. I almost wonder if you could do the plot without him.
I didn’t actively dislike R1, but I don’t know if I’m going to bother watching it again. I’d probably give it a 6/10 if I had to score it.