Hal 9000 said:
I took a quick look at it and there's some very creative work there. I'd definitely watch it as part of a "fun" view of the saga, alongside stuff like the "Funked Up" TPM, Grindhouse ANH, etc. I don't mean it to sound derogatory, just that it looks more like a fun option than a theatrical cut.
I tried watching it last night and it was barely watchable for me. Partly because I remembered all the edits I made, partly because I spliced in footage and music from other films and while that didn't used to bother me, it does now. Partly because the ADR work would have needed to have been redone professionally, and probably because for what I was trying to do, additional footage would have had to have been shot.
I was just trying to make the most out of the movie; I think someone said it best when they said it was a great "proof of concept." In terms of the music flowing and the editing making sense and being synchronized to the music, I'd say this edit ranks up there with the best of them.