Detective

Lord Haseo said:

jedimasterobiwan said:

Lord Haseo said:

jedimasterobiwan said:

sonofjones said:

I gotta agree, I don't think it matters what it is. Whether some garbage, Luke's hand, some gadget or whatever, I think it's there just to highlight the dangerous situation Luke's in as he hangs for dear life above a bottomless abyss of clouds, which marks this as his lowest point in the entire saga. 

 Wouldn't that be when he underestimated  the powers of the emperor. Yoda warned him after all. Also the whole beginning of jedi was all leia's fault she didn't let han pay off his debt to jabba man how selfish was she.

No...Luke had his hand cut off and had just been told that his father was Darth Vader. That in conjuncture with Han being in Carbonite marks this as the lowest point in the saga. Not only that the  film just ends....no resolution no spark of happiness like in the ending STAR WARS and Return of The Jedi...nothing but bleakness with the tinniest speck of hope. 

Makes you want to watch ROTJ immediately afterward though. 

 True but the point i was making was the fact that luke the hero didn't even beat the emperor. The redeemed anakin skywalker did. So him getting beat by the emperor might better almost a lower point if you get what i mean.

 Luke was the dumb ass who threw his fucking lightsaber away just to make a point. It's not as though Sidious beat him in combat.

 If I may...

When Luke throws his lightsaber away, this was probably closer to the highest point of Luke's life...  He DID beat the emperor - since the emperor's goal was to turn Luke to the dark side.  That was the competition, and Luke won.

OT: I'm torn between wanting to watch the latest video or not...  I usually don't watch trailers for movies I want to see, since they're traditionally spoileriffic - and this feels similar...

Either way, Adywan, thank you and your team for your dedication!  Can't wait to watch this whenever it's released!  Everything I have seen is amazing...