Marlonius

One item I haven't seen mentioned as a fix:

When Han first peeks over the snowbank while tracking the Probot, the debris from the Probot's demise is already there. Obviously this little gaffe was created in the editing room, but perhaps Ady can fix it.

Also, while watching Empire with my wife this a.m., she noticed that during the AT-AT battle, Luke calls Wedge both Rogue 2 and Rogue 3. (This is in the lead up to the harpoon scene).

...and back into lurking I go.

M>

One item I haven't seen mentioned or suggested: it would be great to see the snowspeeder's flaps working through the windows in one or 2 of the cockpit shots. In the model shots, those flaps are moving constantly, but whenever they cut to an interior shot, they don't move at all. I don't know what would be involved in modelling them, but I put it out for consideration.

Cheers,

M.

I was personally thrilled with Adywan's work, but still have a few suggestions. Some of them may be impossible, but I'll mention them all anyway, just to have them out there.

Trash Compactor - I'd like to see the squeaky sound of the styrofoam garbage eliminated. Also, in some scenes the trash liquid level is only mid-shin on the actors. Luke gets snatched into water that is 9 inches deep, and then can't be found. If there was some way to transpose the the liquid level up to mid thigh depth, it would make it much more plausible that a monster could be in there.

Yavin Hangar - As we know, one full sized prop was used for all the X wings. It would be nice if the red stripe on Luke's full sized ship could be broken to match the filming miniature. I have good photo refs of each filming miniature if anyone is interested.

Space Battle - As per above, the 2004 DVD (i.e. the 1997 Special Edition) replaced many model shots with CGI, and used Wedge's Red 2 model for every ship. It would be nice to have the Red stripe broken up to better match the Red 5 model here too. I know Ady added more hash marks to the wings in some shots, but missed the stripe on the forward fuselage.

Yavin Base - I dearly miss seeing 3P0 look at Leia when Luke announces that he's lost R2. That moment always cemented 3P0's real concern for his buddy and I can't understand why Ady chose to leave it out.

Millenium Falcon Cockpit - the horizontal light panel on the wall behind Han doesn't line up when it rounds the corner from the back wall to the side wall. Chewie's side is straight, and both sides are perfect in ESB. It's as though the set builders made a mistake. I'd love to see that fixed, but again I don't know how.

This is my first post, so let me say that I'm thrilled to see the good work being done here. Cheers, M.