logo Sign In

SilverWook

User Group
Moderators
Join date
9-Dec-2004
Last activity
6-Apr-2023
Posts
22,080

Post History

Post
#326979
Topic
The 2008 '<strong>The Clone Wars</strong>' animated theatrical movie - a general discussion thread
Time

I never meant to imply it didn't get great reviews.

In the end, if you like a movie and the critics don't, (or vice-versa) what does it matter?

I honestly can't name very many critics beyond Roger Ebert and the late Gene Siskel. I didn't even know Rex Reed was still around until someone mentioned elsewhere he panned The Dark Knight!

And when a good review is in short supply, the studios quote someone you've never heard of from an obscure source. And if you're Sony, you invent a critic who always praises your films. ;)

 

Post
#326901
Topic
The 2008 '<strong>The Clone Wars</strong>' animated theatrical movie - a general discussion thread
Time

Did you guys know Robert Clampett wanted to make an animated John Carter back in the 30's? The test animation was included in the huge supplemental section on the Beany and Cecil DVD.

It's amazing stuff when you consider animation wasn't usually thought of as a medium for serious storytelling at the time.

Post
#326866
Topic
The 2008 '<strong>The Clone Wars</strong>' animated theatrical movie - a general discussion thread
Time

At least one local theater chain has been running behind the scene featurettes in those video loops that run long before the movies start here.

I still sort of hope this would open the door to a post ROTJ movie with Luke and the gang. Catching up with Dr. Jones after all these years makes me really want to see how the galaxy far far away is getting along.

No question Mark Hamill would do it. He did Luke on the radio, and voicing cartoon characters is his bread and butter!

I would imagine they could get just about everyone else except Harrison Ford. Perry King did an excellent Han Solo in the radio dramas though!

 

Post
#326686
Topic
The establishing shots of OOT compared to the '97 special edition and '04 DVDs.
Time

According to Once Upon A Galaxy, it's the little scene where Luke is suiting up in the Medical Center and chatting with 2-1B before the big battle on Hoth. Kershner asked Lucas to help out after catching him peering through a camera viewfinder. Lucas allegedly did many takes.

Once Upon A Galaxy is such a great snapshot of what it was really like on the Empire set. I'm really hoping they follow up that recent making of Star Wars book, and reprint it. My copy is falling apart!

Post
#326590
Topic
Is laserdisc better than VHS?
Time

The first widescreen LD was probably Woody Allen's "Manhattan". He had the clout to demand it be letterboxed from it's first video release in 1984. This included VHS, Beta, and tv broadcasts of the film! (All these early video versions have gray instead of black bars.) I don't think a pan and scan version even exists.

 

Believe it or not, the honor of the first ever widescreen video release of a movie actually goes to CED!

http://www.cedmagic.com/featured/amarcord.html

Post
#326581
Topic
Is laserdisc better than VHS?
Time

VHS and LD were never really in direct competition with each other. The average consumer didn't know it existed, or confused it with RCA's CED videodisc format.

Laserdisc carved out it's own niche with the early home theater crowd. That lasted until DVD came along, but just about everything DVD is today is because of LD.

Digital sound, Dolby Digital, DTS, letterboxing, commentary tracks, supplemental material, even anamorphic widescreen all first appeared on those big shiny discs.

Laserdisc recorders did exist. But only in the expensive realm of professional broadcast gear. A blank disc could cost hundreds of dollars!

Lucasfilm's famous Editdroid system used LD too.

I should mention many VHS decks made in the late 90's onward have "quasi S-VHS playback", although it wasn't often mentioned as a feature. Simply put, they can play S-VHS tapes back but at regular VHS resolution.

Post
#326576
Topic
The 2008 '<strong>The Clone Wars</strong>' animated theatrical movie - a general discussion thread
Time

Pixar rendered "A Bug's Life" twice. One version was for theaters/widescreen video and another for home video to avoid pan and scan. Characters were repositioned and camera placement changed for the full frame video version.

Lucasfilm could have done the same here with enough lead time before the theatrical release.

Post
#326441
Topic
Hey, did you hear they came out with a DVD for that &quot;Star Wars&quot; movie last year?
Time

I can't really imagine Star Wars ever bombing. At worst, it would have been "moderately successful, like a Disney film" as Lucas expected, and he would have gone ahead with Splinter of the Mind's Eye.

If you stumble across a Universe where Splinter was actually made, please bring a DVD of it back with you. ;)

 

Post
#325582
Topic
Info Wanted: Two Questions
Time
negative1 said:

doesn't disney pull the exact same stunts but worse..

 

i remember them saying the films were going to keep going back into the vault,

and here we are decades later, with 10 different formats, versions, and special

editions of the dvd's also?

Yeah, Disney pretty much ran this scam into the ground. Back in the glory days of VHS, they proclaimed Snow White and Fantasia would only ever be released on video once. Prior to that, Snow White was in the "when hell freezes over" video relase schedule. ;)

This is probably why nobody really took the "Last chance to own the original version of Star Wars" ads seriously.