logo Sign In

SilverWook

User Group
Moderators
Join date
9-Dec-2004
Last activity
6-Apr-2023
Posts
22,080

Post History

Post
#522880
Topic
Star Wars coming to Blu Ray (UPDATE: August 30 2011, No! NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!)
Time

digitalfreaknyc said:

[quote=SilverWook]



Which probably means we get the same edited version of SPFX that has always been on video, or worse yet, the 90's version of Making of Star Wars that replaces William Conrad's original narration. :(


How was SPFX edited?

 

Some clips from a couple Disney films apparently couldn't be cleared for home video, and were chopped out. This makes Mark Hamill's reference to them later on in the doc rather cryptic. An uncut version recorded from an European broadcast has been spotted on Youtube.

Post
#522873
Topic
Star Wars coming to Blu Ray (UPDATE: August 30 2011, No! NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!)
Time

adywan said:

Well it doesn't loon  good for the special features disc (disc 9) for anyone hoping that we're going to get high quality versions of the old docs. Looks like Lucas is pulling a 2006 bonus DVD on us again. I've been having some PM's with someone that knows a bit about the sources used for the discs and i was sent this reply (edited to removed clues to identity)

Ady

After your recent conversations with [deleted] i was asked to contact you because i have a little more knowledge on this subject.

I do know that there have been some minor color alterations but i cannot comment on the extent because this was not my department.

The original special feature documentaries will only be on the final disc in the complete saga collection. These, however, could only be presented in standard definition. While there are copies of 16mm prints for these documentaries, there was no green light given to use these for the source of the special features. Instructions were given to find the digital masters which were used for the original release versions. I am unsure if these were the same used for the VHS or laserdisc copies but a colleague informed me that these masters were produced in the 1980's or 1990's (although i cannot confirm this). As far as i am aware no post production work was done on these masters  to prepare them for the Blu-Ray collection. Having seen [deleted] at [deleted] there seems to be some issues with digital artefacts caused by the interlaced source used and from the original digital conversion. The same procedure was used for some deleted scenes seen in the Empire of Dreams documentary as these scenes were also taken from older digital copies.

He went on to give me some more information that i cannot post here because it may reveal his identity. So it doesn't look good for all of the original trilogy stuff then :(

Which probably means we get the same edited version of SPFX that has always been on video, or worse yet, the 90's version of Making of Star Wars that replaces William Conrad's original narration. :(

Classic Creatures seems to have been edited on broadcast videotape, so there may be no 16mm prints anyway.

Post
#522508
Topic
What did you like.......about the '97 Special Editions?
Time

DuracellEnergizer said:

 

SilverWook said:

And we all know the stormtroopers eventually moved in on the crowds celebrating on Coruscant. ;)


Another thing to like about the EU =D

 

Really? I thought it was just my own personal canon.  Just like I imagine a blaster shot taking down the Gungan who shouts "Weesa Free!". ;)

And I'm still waiting for George to include that shot of Jimmy Smits in old age makeup secretly filmed during production of ROTS...

Post
#522454
Topic
What did you like.......about the '97 Special Editions?
Time

timdiggerm said:

Star Wars:

Falcon leaving Mos Eisley

DS battle

Empire:

Eh, the Wampa, I guess? Eh.

Return:

The ending celebration. I was skeptical at first, but I've come to realize it's a much better ending than "Celebrate the loooooooooove" and the galactic perspective is really nice, particularly in light of the prequels.

But if you realize the Empire is not spread so thin as to collapse in a day, it kind of falls apart. Who the heck are all those people on Cloud City anyway? Everybody fled when the Lando warned the Empire was in town.

Also, people dancing around in 120 degree heat in Mos Eisley is just plain suicidal. Thank goodness the rumor of an added shot of an elderly Watto shedding tears of happiness turned out to be bogus.

And we all know the stormtroopers eventually moved in on the crowds celebrating on Coruscant. ;)

Post
#521275
Topic
Star Wars Inconsistencies
Time

Bingowings said:

Han accidentally finding himself in a system with one inhabited planet, the main city of which is being run by the guy who previously owned the ship he is sitting in, is the sort of galaxy shrinking coincidence that Anchorhead doesn't like and he likes bees.

Maybe the fleet travelled quite a distance with the Falcon sitting on the back of The Avenger (without anyone else in the fleet noticing it)? 

Drones of the Empire don't get paid to look out the window. There doesn't seem to be any windows on the back end of a Star Destroyer either. ;)

Post
#521226
Topic
Star Wars Inconsistencies
Time

Bingowings said:

According to Nookiepedia Bespin is in the Bespin system, the Anoat system is just where the fleet break up and Han pauses to study his options.

So the journey from Hoth to that point (at sub-light speeds) has already taken the Falcon across inter-stella space into another system.

It was a long time ago in another galaxy so maybe they packed star systems a lot closer back then in that place.

 

One of my old magazines is either in error, or Lucas changed his mind about Bespin's location since the 80's. ;)

Post
#521213
Topic
Star Wars Inconsistencies
Time

The Imperials don't know the Hyperdrive is busted. Admiral Piett even speculates the Falcon "could be half way across the Galaxy by now". This is why the fleet disperses and goes to light speed, leaving the area.

Boba Fett is doing a balancing act trying to get a paycheck from the Empire and Jabba, so he's probably not going to phone Vader up until he's sure where the Falcon is going, and without those four other bounty hunters finding out or being close enough to intervene. It's unlikely he's going to let the Falcon out of his sight.

Bespin is a planet of the Anoat system. (There is no third system that they travel to.) Lando states the mining operation is too small for the Empire to notice or care about.