Sevb32

Reviews should not be allowed until the set is released. Amazon.com needs to overhaul their review system. They've needed to for years.

Uncanny Antman said:

miker71 said:

FWIW, it doesn't sound like JEJ to me either. Maybe one day I'll do a frequency spectrum comparison, but maybe not.

I've never believed it either.  And for the record, I doubt that some of Vader's dialogue from Ep III is JEJ too.   "Where is Padme?  Is she safe, is she alright?" sounds like him, but the following lines about "I?  I couldn't have, she was alive!" sound very un-JEJ to me.  They seem 'thin' and processed just like the "Prepare for my arrival" from ESB.

The June 2005 issue of Starlog magazine talks about how JEJ worked at least one day recording dialogue for ROTS.

Also, someone brought up amazon.com reviews. I have thought for years that their review system is a joke, I think it's ridiculous that they allow reviews of things that are not even out yet, and they lump all releases in the same review as a previous release(s) of the same movies. Reviews should be a well-rounded reviews of the entire set, not just half or less.

digitalfreaknyc said:

Sevb32 said:

That's why I hate some of the things people post in here, wishing or not minding death of someone over because you disagree with something they did or didn't do involving an entertainment form. Overboard. Big time.

There's a difference between wishing death on someone and what I said. Everyone is going to die...including George Lucas. I was just speculating as to what will happen when that inevitably does happen.

 He could already have legal stuff put in place on what happens when he dies, so it may not matter anyway.

That's why I hate some of the things people post in here, wishing or not minding death of someone over because you disagree with something they did or didn't do involving an entertainment form. Overboard. Big time. I'm sure some blu-ray.com forum people would like to crash the forums here, two wrongs don't make a right, though.

It was Obi-Wan's opinion that Anakin had been a good friend, and as shown in ROTS specifically, he was giving Anakin high praise during their last meeting on good terms. There is enough there, just not enough for you.

Can't believe some of this stuff is still being brought up. Who ever said a Jedi can not have more than one Jedi Master training them during their life? One of Obi-Wan's first lines in TPM was "....but Master Yoda told me I should be mindful of the future." Plus the fact that Yoda was showing teaching some of the younger ones. Vague statements were used in the OT that gave wiggle room for additions and more detail.

I saw some people complaining about quality control (how they missed this frame) earlier, not just that it could be the same transfer.

What is it about one frame? Unless you freeze frame it you can't see it! I am betting a lot films have similar flaws they just don't have as many frame by frame obsessive compulsive eyes on them as the Star Wars films do.

There is no need to add breath to the really outdoor scenes as they were really shot outdoors in the cold.

No way to "hand" paint out the matte for the few frames it is?

Another small thing I would like to see tweaked that wasn't in the first versions was the CG C3PO on the landspeeder in the side view pan zoom by approach of Mos Eisley. C3PO needs his color muted a bit, it's too strong of a color.

What about Anakin's shaggy haircut in ROTS? Sideburns and shaggy hair were not prevelant in the 1950s, but were in the 70s. Kind of like in prequels they weren't common, like in the OT they were. Hairstyles has nothing to do with technology, though.

But how many people beside us obsessive geeks would notice that about the vest? All the films reused stuff, you can see the Tantive IV wall panes reused on the SD Bridge in ESB, and other stuff, etc.

I like to think he had a twin brother. 

Truthfully we are probably are at least 5 years away from ROTJ:R being done. (Just stating likely facts)

LOL It's the best way to get people talking. Even if it brings insults to me, at least there is activity.

RIP thread.

There is a flying creature in the ROTS deleted Dagobah scenes, it doesn't glow.

The fact he is doing this in HD proves once again he has been known to change his mind about things, more than once he said he wouldn't be going back to it. Cool!

Anyone have an HD source of REVENGE OF THE SITH? He could probably use some of those elements from the deleted Dagobah scene for some the Dagobah creatures in ESB. If he likes those enough, that is.

There were a few little creatures seen in the ROTS deleted scene where Yoda lands on Dagobah, some of which had lights on them.

I've seen it in real life.

Maybe it's the mood or tone for the situation that accounts for the way Leia pronounces "Han".

vbangle said:

Ghostbusters said:

I've heard about this Sevb kid, Adywan told me about him, but I haven't noticed him. He sounded like an annoying prick that doesn't appreciate the effort put into this (sorry for sounding hypocritical here).

You are twins, separated at birth.

 Let's see, I've donated a few times, and I sometimes (and often go months between asks) ask for a new still or clips and I am treated like a murderer in here by a few. Ady once or twice gave me what I asked for, for example he went with my early suggestion of one new still a week for a while. I mean if someone was bending enough and gave what you asked for in the past, wouldn't you see if they'd do it again once in a while? Vbangle, you've treated other people like crap here too, for daring say anything you didn't agree with.

Just some thoughts...

I liked that he removed the yellow/green color from the panel room when piet informs vader.

Palpatine's clarity and the quality of the hologram is top notch.

I see he replaced again the top section of the background when we see palpatine's face from front.

There is  too much interference and shaking in the holo.

Quality noise in between frames that shows the noise/tremble effect.

Behind palpatine the background looks too static. There was a little light that were blinking in the dark rentagle in the wall.

The audio is temp but still i judge what i saw. The lip sync was poor.

Vader's close up after a while was reversed footage.

I like but i dont if its correct that the lines in the side view to be angled and even the holo animation lines follow that. i like the aggresive look still it might be an artistic choice.

The glow in the emperor's side view was too clean. was begging for some grain
The changes between the clean and the distorted signal are way too fast. if they could be slightly slowed down it would be ideal.

Also, Ady where did you get the side view element of the hologram? It lines up perfectly with the lighting on the hood in the front view!