Hello, I’m new here, and as much as I enjoy other peoples opinions, 164 pages of comments is just to much to catch up on! So I’ll just add my two cents.
The Luke/Rey/Kylo storyline, what I’ll call the “A” plot, had its moments. I thought it was a lot like The Force Awakens in that though it was often kind of stupid, it was still enjoyable.
The “B” plot with everyone else was terrible. This plot line was dumb. The characters were dumb (I really can’t get over the fact that Poe, Finn, and Rose got almost everyone killed!) The comedy was dumb except for a few good 3PO moments. But worst of all, I was bored most of time.
Everything I enjoyed was in the “A” plot, and even there I was disappointed by Luke’s character.
I put this one in 7th place out of 9 for the whole franchise.