corellian77 said:
Lord Grievous said:
This latest version has his right eye so dark it seems like he's got a black eye, and that smile (in my opinion) doesn't belong there.
Although this whole thing is now academic, since Ady has said he's happy with this clip and is done with it, I just wanted to reply to this. Regarding the "black eye", yeah, I guess upon comparing both images, the shadow over the Emperor's left eye (our right) does seem more pronounced in the newer clip. However, it's just showing what was already there. Having brightened the image may, therefore, be questionable to some, but it does bring it visually more in line with the other holograms in the saga.
As for the Emperor not smiling...
what movie are you watching? ;)
I never said he doesn't smile, I also never said that the smile looks fake, I merely said that I think he shouldn't smile in that particular scene.
This isn't open for discussion, this is just my opinion on this scene. I think it looked fine before with Ady's previous version. If you don't agree than fine, but this isn't some theory you can (dis-)prove or not.
Every single page of this thread is filled with people saying they don't like or do like some change Ady has made. It's his edit, but if everyone else here can make 500 word posts about some change they want pushed through then I don't see why I can't make a comment on something I disagree with.