DarthBo

Ghost said:

Does anyone think that Vader's entrance in the Hoth battle is weak?  He comes out of nowhere.

Ghost said:

Why isn't there going to be a ground battle on Hoth?  I know that it would take alot of time to do, but it would make sense if there was one added.  Mabey if Lucas does an edit, this will be added.

Ghost said:

I think some PT music should be added.  Nothing noticible, but just background music.  The PT's music is much more epic than hearing the same old Imperial March every scene.

Ghost said:

Mix in a sad version of force theme from the PT when the Empire its close to winning.

At least add some epic music to the Vader/Luke scene.

I don't get what you want to achieve with this thread...

What films a faneditor works on his decision, not yours, not ours.

lol, great work as always, Fishmanlee!

I love how you skilfully edited the words 'adywan' and 'watched' into the text on the back.

Bingowings said:

I've got nothing against subtitles on non-English language movies when there's no action but films like Star Wars shouldn't be overly subtitled, otherwise you can't see the worlds for the reading.

SomethingStarWarsRelated said:
And Adywan is gonna be using the HD version right? So he won't be able to crop any of the images...is that correct?

Darth Venal said:

EyeShotFirst:

It was nice but they should never add a character when the actor who played them died. IN ANY FILM. At least Alec Guiness was still alive when Ewan McGregor took over the role.

What does that even mean? Was it a joke?

It's the sanctuary moon, Roman soldiers have nothing to do with it ;-)

Monroville said:

Did anyone notice how the Emperor wonders how Vader knew that Luke was with the rebel troops on Endor and yet tells Vader Luke will go to him, as he has forseen it?  Isn't that a little odd or is it just STAR WARS?

Palpatine knew Luke would be coming, but didn't sense his arrival. 

That's how I always understood that scene anyway

I don't see the point in putting an avatar in front of the thread title either, it's confusing if anything...

I still don't understand why you want to replace his hair?!

When we get older we lose hair, end of story.

dude, this question was answered a million times already, just go a few pages back

Bingowings said:

I swear I'm not doing this just to be contrary but if Geonosis is to be less orange perhaps Kamino should be a bit more :

Essentially both locations are doing the same thing (building an army for Palpatine/Sidious) overlapping the two would underline that.

 

I can't stop looking at this, did you paint it?

Do you have it in a higher resolution?

In any case, I'm a supporter of every edit that gives the AOTC planets more than one colour.

EDIT

silly me, I should've just looked at the image url ^^

Yes, more blue!

Now it fits in with the OT!

Oh don't get me wrong Bingo, I still like what Angel does, it's just that I don't like the crushed blacks. Only space should be that black ;-)

You edited Angel's mockup of the glass hallway on Kamino: you make the blacks lighter, and blurred everything somewhat so you wouldn't see too many details everywhere. I think your version looks better.

SilverKey said:

What I meant is that sometimes, in my opinion, you boost the contrast too much, which makes some of the shots look a little unnatural because we're seeing way too much. Your adjustments make every little detail visible, and that makes the shots kind of "flat". All the subtleties are gone, and every little detail is there, screaming for our attention.

An example: the shot of Amidala's ship landing on Coruscant in AOTC. The platform is very "busy" now with every little thing we see on it. I like that the original shot was a little more "quiet".

I don't mean to rag on your and others' color adjustment work, but I think there is a little too much of a "Let's make it more dark and faded and it'll look like the OT!"-mentality going on here. 

I agree

I guess if you want to be consistent, removing the few reflections is easier than adding them everywhere else.

EyeShotFirst said:

Hey Ady,

How about you do something similar to Luke's hand. Come on it looks like crap LOL.

Sorry, but the one on the left looks a lot more realistic to me.

You changed the colour from something that looks like real skin to something that looks like it belongs to a corpse...

And why would the inside of Luke's arm need bright blue LEDs and glowing tubes?!

Ziz said:

Um....eyes can move left to right without the head moving.  We are seeing Han from the back when he says "Yeah, that'll do nicely."  Maybe he's glancing at the cave with his peripheral vision but needs to stay focused on working some control on the console.

You fixed the timing of the lines, that's enough.  Don't over-think the rest of it.

Oh come on. You're not telling me you only move your eyes while you're driving?

You don't say "that'll do nicely" without having a good look at it. Han turns his head towards the cave by the end of the scene, if one could edit that to happen sooner, it could work.

oh_riginal said:

RoccondilRinon said:

I like that. C-3PO's shortened line sounds so much more pitiful than the original, that it's almost an improvement.

 

I agree, even though that wasn't my intention at all. I just wanted Han's line to be spoken a second or two later, AFTER the cave appears onscreen, and I could either have had Han's and C-3PO's lines partially overlap, which I didn't want to do, or remove 3PO's line entirely, which I also didn't want to do. So I went halfway with the options. Leia's line is also delayed slightly, to keep the scene from having too big of a dialogue gap altogether.

I'm not a big fan of the shortened line. One problem remains though: Han still doesn't actually _look_ at the cave.

Google the question and get back on topic.

--

There's only two things that always bothered me in ESB. One has already been fixed in the trailer (The Falcon not retracting its landing gear on Bespin), the second is Han pointing at the cave he can't see.

Considering Adywan is rebuilding parts of the asteroid for continuity, I'm fairly sure he'll look at this as well.

Your Palace matte looks nice Darth Venal, but the shadows are very inconsistent. The whole desert plain just doesn't fit in.

Is it a picture of a beach, btw? It's like there's little shells/pebbles everywhere, castings long shadows from a morning/evening sun. 

DuTwan said:

Ive just thought what about if instead on saying luke skywalker in the epilogue, why cant we say he had been known as the starkiller since he indeed destroyed the death star. This is a wink to the old story and make an alias for luke and thus vader tryin to find out who the starkiller is, on top of that the emporer finds out the real name and making the whole hologram scene in the asteriod field. Anybody thinks this is a good idea?

no

Revenge is personal.

All we ever heard in the films is that the Jedi and Sith don't like each other. Is simply killing each other revenge? Revenge for what?

I don't buy "self defense" either, he could've used force pushes or mindtricks. No need to choke people. Luke isn't bound by the same dogmatic rules as the old Jedi anymore, he kind of just does what makes sense to him.

We know the Sith had the Jedi killed, taking revenge for that makes sense.

It is never mentioned in the films why the Sith disappeared, so why would it be revenge?

Anyway, we had this discussion before, les goûts et les couleurs...

I'm not sure I would have bothered watching The Bangs Of The Sith.

:P

That is stunning!

Well done, Angel

We had a big "should it have been Revenge of the Jedi & Return of the Sith?" discussion a while back (I think it was the ESB/ROTJ wishlist thread).

Personally, if Luke can forcechoke guards and slice anyone who gets in his way with his lightsaber, I don't see why he wouldn't be able to take revenge. Anakin (no longer Vader) sure takes revenge on Palpatine.

There wasn't any revenging going on in episode 3 anyway. The Sith just returned "with a bang".

Many here thought the title change was to drastic though, so we just left it there.