logo Sign In

Darth Robin

User Group
Members
Join date
27-Jun-2017
Last activity
4-Jul-2025
Posts
57

Post History

Post
#1655096
Topic
Complete Comparison of Special Edition Visual Changes
Time

Something just struck me: So the version of the movie that had these three unique VFX shots is the limited release version from may 1977, so that’s different from the wide release version, then there’s the 1981 version with the new opening crawl, but these three unique VFX shots from the limited release shots showed up on the 1980’s home video releases, but those had the 81 crawl. So where those VFX shots in the theatrical 1981 cut?

I was under the impression that the the early 80’s VHS releases, prior to the 1985 mix was(aside from cropping) accurate to the 1981 theatrical version, but is that not the case? Are they in fact a mix of the 1981 and May 1977 limited release cuts?

Post
#1652354
Topic
Complete Comparison of Special Edition Visual Changes
Time

Ok I just watched 13las’s (a.k.a tommy blasé) video on changes and he explained this and he had better quality clips to demonstrate. So the temple exterior shot is apparently very slightly out of synk, you can see it looking at the rebel soldiers moving in the shot, and there’s a blue streak for a split second that was the likely reason they changed it.

The X-Wings taking of shot apparently had a cloud removed for the wide release version but honestly I can’t see it so I’ll just take his word for it. lol Honestly how do people notice these things?

Post
#1652118
Topic
How to Watch Star Wars, Part Two: The Special Editions Are the Movies, Get Over It
Time

I just watched the video and while I didn’t disagree with everything he said, like I think when he talked about that Red Letter Media video he kept going back to and The People vs George Lucas, he made very good points and rightly pointed out their many wrong and childish statements. When he went into defending specific special edition changes I agreed with some points, disagreed with others.

All that being said though, the the whole point he’s making with the video is nonsense. The idea that just because it’s Georges movies we don’t deserve to have the original cuts is ridiculous. And so is his assertion that fans wouldn’t be happy even if we got the theatrical cuts in HD because we wouldn’t think it looks good enough, huh, this whole forum disproves that. I also think he was really unfair to Harmy and misrepresented what he’s doing. I like the point that G&G-Fan made earlier in this tread: it’s hypocritical of him to criticize Peter Jackson’s LOTR 4K’s while at the same time chastising star wars fans for doing the same with star wars.

Post
#1540873
Topic
Harmy's RETURN OF THE JEDI Despecialized Edition HD - V3.1
Time

Darth Robin said:

Harmy said:

You probably just need to set the framerate to 23.976 manually.

Oh, I see the option now. Thank you. And thank you for making v.3.0. It looks amazing.

Sigh, seems it wasn’t so simple after all. I didn’t see an option for 23,976 so I picked 24 instead, I figured it didn’t matter, but now the audio is out of synk and I can’t find an option for 23,976 in TSMuxer, so I’m back in square 1 and still need help I’m afraid.

Post
#1540829
Topic
Harmy's RETURN OF THE JEDI Despecialized Edition HD - V3.1
Time

Harmy said:

Darth Robin said:

So cool to see this finnished. I downloaded the 1080p version. I’d like to put this on a blu-ray disc, what software do you all use for that?

tsMuxer is your best bet - it will create a blu-ray iso for you, which you can then burn with any disc burning software. The encode is already BD compatible, so it’s a simple remux and should be pretty fast. If you throw out any audio tracks you don’t need, you should be able to fit it on a single layer BD.

tsMuxer doesn’t seem to work for this one, it just tells me “non standard fps value do not supported for pgs streams”

I’ve tried with so many different softwares at this point but I can’t find one that works.

Post
#1486965
Topic
Frame comparisons
Time

I love the site caps-a-holic.com that lets you choose different releases and compre frames switching in between them quickly. It’s peen particurlarly intressting to compare the 2011 blu-rays to the 2020 blu-rays this way but of cource this site only has screenshots of official releases and I’d love to include TN1’s Star Wars 4K releases in this comparison so I was wondering if there is any sites that lets me compare all three versions and I can flip in between the frames quickly?