logo Sign In

What Laserdisc player do you use for capturing and why?

Author
Date
Author
Time
Post link
I intend to build a PC for capturing in the not-so-distant future and might have to capture a few LDs every now and then. I was wondering which players you favor and why. Also, I was wondering if it was possible to mod the composite output in order to obtain something similar to the X0's output.
Author
Time
Post link
Here's the thing: video is stored on laserdiscs in composite format. Therefore, most players look their best when connected to a modern display via composite video because the display typically has a better comb filter (for converting to S-video) than the LD player does. Only a select few LD players, like the X0 and LD-S9, have comb filters comparable to those in modern displays, which is why their S-video output looks so good.

My current LD player is a CLD-99. I've also owned a CLD-79 and LD-S9 (imported new from Japan, and it breaks my heart whenever I think about having sold it). With composite video output, I found them all very comparable because the display did the heavy lifting. The LD-S9 was probably the sharpest, followed by the CLD-79 and CLD-99, which is a bit soft. Differences in S-video output were more apparent. However, I found the LD-S9's S-video and composite outputs comparable on my display, most likely because the comb filters were about equal in quality.

I think the most important thing for you to worry about is finding a capture card with an exceptional comb filter and an LD player with an exceptional composite output. I've heard the CLD-97 has great composite output, but you'd have to get it modded with an AC-3 output if you planned on capturing Dolby Digital soundtracks.
Forum Administrator

MTFBWY…A

Author
Time
Post link
What of the players you mention allow for capturing of Dolby Digital soundtracks without having to be modded?
Author
Time
Post link
The CLD-79, CLD-99, and LD-S9 all have AC-3 outputs. These outputs, when fed into an RF demodulator, output a Dolby Digital signal. Not sure about the X0.
Forum Administrator

MTFBWY…A

Author
Time
Post link
Why did you change from the LD-S9 or even the CLD-79 to the CLD-99?
Author
Time
Post link
I needed the money. I sold my LD-S9 for $1700 and my CLD-79, which was my secondary LD player, for $500 I believe. At the time, I was planning to get rid of my LDs. I bought the CLD-99 last year because I got a good deal on it and I still like to watch some of my LDs on occasion.

I definitely wish I still had the LD-S9. I probably will again someday (or an X0 if I'm doing particularly well financially).
Forum Administrator

MTFBWY…A

Author
Time
Post link
I use a Pioneer CLD-79 Elite Player now,and i friggin love it.
DJ
Author
Time
Post link
Wassup, dark_jedi? I'm sorry I haven't helped you with Blade Runner yet, I've been occupied doing some other stuff.
Author
Time
Post link
No worries Byakko,your here now,Dide'e is also looking into it for me.
DJ
Author
Time
Post link
I really love my Pioneer DVL-700. It was the last decent American model and has a first generation DVD player in it. The comb filter is pretty good, not X0 good, but pretty good. Captures turn out reasonably well.
http://www.retcon.net