Ranking the MCU Movies

I don’t know if this thread isn’t already exist but page 7 not see.

1. The Avengers
   [No comment]

2. The Incredible Hulk
   What an amazing rollercoaster of a movie, from beginning to the end. I liked the villain, I liked the Hulk, I liked Banner, I liked the colonel, I liked the girlfriend. It’s hard to find flaws here.

3. Captain America: The Winter Soldier
   Holy sh*t now this is what happens when you put a cool twist on a superhero movie. It’s not really a superhero film, it’s a spy movie with superheroes in it. I was sitting at the edge of my seat the entire time.

4. Captain America: The First Avenger
   Red Skull was a big dissapointment, he was a very 1-dimensional villain. He worked better when he had the human face mask thing and the actor could actually act properly. The WW2 setting was handled really well. It kinda makes me sad we probably won’t get another Marvel movie which is set in WW2.

5. Avengers: Age of Ultron
   Tries bit too much in places, some scenes feel out of place, but it’s nice to finally see the Avengers realizing that something is going on with the infinity stones.

6. Ant-Man
   As a finale it falls flat on it’s face, but it’s a good movie.

7. Iron Man
   Confident but grounded movie. It’s not trying any complicated universe-building plot, and that’s why it works so well. Marvel needs to make more movies like this.

8. Iron Man 3
   Tony hiding and collecting information about Mandarin and dealing with his PTSD of The Avengers is simply amazing emotional journey, and I love the ending speech. The final battle is underwhelming though.

9. Thor: The Dark World
   Worth watching for Loki alone.

10. Iron Man 2
    Tries too much at the same time, but it comes together nicely at the end. Still pretty fun.

11. Guardians of the Galaxy
    Strangely paced, the villain wasn’t that great and it didn’t explain many things about the aliens (basic stuff, like cultures, politics etc.).

12. Thor
    ZZZzzzzzzzzzzzzz…

Will add Civil War once I rewatch it properly.

HansiG said:

I don’t know if this thread isn’t already exist but page 7 not see.

The Avengers
The Incredible Hulk
Captain America: The Winter Soldier
Avengers: Age of Ultron
Captain America: The First Avenger
Iron Man
Iron Man 3
Thor: The Dark World
Iron Man 2
Guardians of the Galaxy
Thor

I don’t even like superhero movies and I thought GotG was good.

#beingHansi

Neglify said:

1. Guardians of the Galaxy

Yeah I don’t think anybody is going to agree with you on that one.

Except me.

❤️

right now …

1. Iron Man
2. The Avengers
3. Captain America - Winter Soldier
4. Captain America - Civil War
5. Thor
6. Captain America - First Avenger
7. Iron Man 2
8. Iron Man 3
9. Guardians of the Galaxy
10. Ant-man
11. Avengers - The Age of Ultron
12. Thor - The Dark World
13. The Incredible Hulk

The Avengers: Well paced, colorful fun from start to finish. Great characters.
Guardians of the Galaxy: Well paced, colorful fun from start to finish. Great characters.
Avengers Ultron: Enjoyed Spader’s Ultron. Not enough of him developing his philosophy or the back-and-forth with his “father”. Probably would have been even better as a colorful standalone like the first rather than a dark middle act/movement episode.
CapAm Civil War: Major problems, but the airport fight and Stark/Parker go along way. Lamest…supervillain…EVER!! Some truck driver from the suburbs of Whateverovia is suddenly an international criminal/terrorist mastermind? He’s upset about his family, so he blows up other peoples families? He can’t figure out that his family would have died in the “meteor” strike anyway? 2 and 1/2 movies where the center of the universe is some guy who used to go fishing with Rogers before he got a prosthetic arm that’s not made out of plastic. Might have worked better with Bucky as the villain out there and the Scarlet Witch as the ambiguous character being arrested and maybe used for study by the ambiguous authorities. Everyone is right, everyone is wrong murkiness and possible conspiracies.
CapAm Winter Soldier: Appreciated the Bourne/MI experimentation.
Thor: Small with odd logistics, but I appreciated the fun characters and offworld worldbuilding.
Iron Man: Stark carries the movie.
Iron Man 3: Good until the end. Needed a stronger climax with Stark down on his back about to go out and suddenly overcoming his fears in a “Wait a second, I’m Tony frick’n STARK” type of moment. No more Mopey Tony thereafter.
Antman: Mild and small. Endearing due to it’s fine cast.
Thor 2: More odd logistics. Cast saves it. Liked it, but not overwhelmed.
Haven’t seen the others.

LuckyGungan2001 said:

HansiG said:

Will add Ant-Man and Civil War once I watch them

HansiG said:

Tyrphanax said:

Ugh I am so stupid excited for Civil War. Just. Ughhhh.

#TeamIronMan

Already seen it 😛

That’s like, month ago. I can’t rate a movie properly until I watched it in the comfort of my own home.

As for my cinematic experience, it was pretty good. I’d put it between Ultron and Winter Soldier.

moviefreakedmind said:

I liked Guardians of the Galaxy. I wouldn’t even really count it as a superhero movie.

That’s why it was good.

thejediknighthusezni said:

The Avengers: Well paced, colorful fun from start to finish. Great characters.
Guardians of the Galaxy: Well paced, colorful fun from start to finish. Great characters.
Avengers Ultron: Enjoyed Spader’s Ultron. Not enough of him developing his philosophy or the back-and-forth with his “father”. Probably would have been even better as a colorful standalone like the first rather than a dark middle act/movement episode.
CapAm Civil War: Major problems, but the airport fight and Stark/Parker go along way. Lamest…supervillain…EVER!! Some truck driver from the suburbs of Whateverovia is suddenly an international criminal/terrorist mastermind? He’s upset about his family, so he blows up other peoples families? He can’t figure out that his family would have died in the “meteor” strike anyway? 2 and 1/2 movies where the center of the universe is some guy who used to go fishing with Rogers before he got a prosthetic arm that’s not made out of plastic. Might have worked better with Bucky as the villain out there and the Scarlet Witch as the ambiguous character being arrested and maybe used for study by the ambiguous authorities. Everyone is right, everyone is wrong murkiness and possible conspiracies.
CapAm Winter Soldier: Appreciated the Bourne/MI experimentation.
Thor: Small with odd logistics, but I appreciated the fun characters and offworld worldbuilding.
Iron Man: Stark carries the movie.
Iron Man 3: Good until the end. Needed a stronger climax with Stark down on his back about to go out and suddenly overcoming his fears in a “Wait a second, I’m Tony frick’n STARK” type of moment. No more Mopey Tony thereafter.
Antman: Mild and small. Endearing due to it’s fine cast.
Thor 2: More odd logistics. Cast saves it. Liked it, but not overwhelmed.
Haven’t seen the others.

Semi-normal formatting.

Is it better that you’re an asshole rather than an idiot?

1. The Avengers (we have to call it “Avengers Assemble” where I live so I might well be breaking the law by writing that horrid foreign title)

2. Captain America - The Winter Soldier

3. Iron Man

4. Captain America - Civil War

5. Ant-Man

6. Avengers - Age of Ultron

7. Thor

8. Iron Man Three

9. The Incredible Sulk

10. Thor - The Dark World

11. Guardians of the Galaxy

12. Captain America - The First Avenger

13. Iron Man 2

I rate all the MCU movies very highly so having to put them in a list like this seems unfair. I don’t hate the ones at the bottom, I just love them slightly less than the ones at the top.

In the UK there was a tv series called “The Avengers”. Some genius in the marketing department decided we Brits might get confused between that forty year old show and the entirely unconnected Marvel superteam. The name of the movie was changed to “Avengers Assemble” and has remained such for the DVD release and tv broadcasts.

We also got the blade sticking out of Coulson’s chest digitally removed and no Joss Whedon audio commentary. I imported my Blu-Ray from the US.

That showed 'em.

suspiciouscoffee said:

11. Thor Pretty bland other than Loki. Thor’s scientist friends’ intern is incredibly annoying, Thor is suddenly worthy despite not actually changing at all. C-

I politely disagree with your view on Thor. Thor becomes worthy for a good reason, not suddenly, or for no reason at all.

He learns honor and humility by sacrificing himself for people he doesn’t even know (Planet Earth). This is not how Thor starts out in the film. He is arrogant and does not care about the consequences of actions he wants to take, i.e. going head first in to battle with the Frost Giants, and what damage it could bring to his own people.

It might be subtly portrayed but it is there.

suspiciouscoffee said:

11. Thor Pretty bland other than Loki. Thor’s scientist friends’ intern is incredibly annoying, Thor is suddenly worthy despite not actually changing at all. C-

I politely disagree with your view on Thor. Thor becomes worthy for a good reason, not just suddenly, and/or for no reason at all.

He learns honor and humility by sacrificing himself for people he doesn’t even know (Planet Earth). This is not how Thor starts out in the film. He is arrogant and does not care about the consequences of actions he wants to take, i.e. going head first in to battle with the Frost Giants, and what damage it could bring to his own people.

It might be subtly portrayed but it is there.

Hate ranking without explanation but don’t want to explain now. Maybe later.

This is a constantly changing list. Here’s how I feel now.

1. Iron Man B+
2. The Avengers B+
3. Guardians of the Galaxy B+
4. Captain America: Civil War B+
5. Captain America: The Winter Soldier B+
6. Iron Man 3 B
7. Captain America: The First Avenger B-
8. The Incredible Hulk B-
9. Thor B-
10. The Avengers: Age of Ultron C+
11. Iron Man 2 C+
12. Ant-Man C
13. Thor: The Dark World C-

My ranking based on personal preference.

1. Captain America Civil War

2. The Avengers

3. Captain America The winter soldier

4. Guardians of the Galaxy

5. Iron man

6. Ant Man

7. Avengers age of ultron

8. Captain America the first avenger

9. Thor

10. Thor the dark world

11. Iron Man 3

12. Iron man 2

13. The Incredible Hulk