Sean you got to be the king of 3 word posts. LOL. I am not sure what that means, exactly, but fake is not better in terms of poorly executed CGI. And like Luke said the matrix and LOTR were certainly much better (I, Robot too). Some of the CG in EP I and II is inexcusable from a man that has more money at his disposal than God and has Skywalker Sound and ILM. Even the new Jabba inserted in the box set looks silly. Gollum is much better than even the highly touted Yoda CG. Episode I is worse than II, looking fully cartoony in parts. I preferred the models and costumes, it was real, just scaled down. Poorly executed CG gives us movies like the Hulk, and I'll pass. Done well, it can look good, done ok...it just ruins a movie for me.