logo Sign In

Post #970744

Author
marduk666
Parent topic
Star Wars: A Galaxy Betrayed – A 3-in-1 edit of the prequels - Released
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/970744/action/topic#970744
Date created
17-Jul-2016, 2:27 PM

I Just Watched it end to end… and great job man!
Easily my favorite III in I I have seen so far. I really got into it. You really made it work. Great Picture and Sound. Thanks, I’m Glad I watched it. I Missed almost nothing that was cut.

It’s good people-- Watch it –

More precice feedback

spoiler
If I could make any suggestions it would be
1 original 20th century fox logo and Lucasfilm logo
2 remove/ Matt out r2d2 from padmes room
3 the Imperial March during the transition is executed very well but the audio on that is noticably different
4 Although what is left of Grevious is pulled off awsomely, and astonishingly almost believable,(not the chase scene on the lizard that still bothers me but it’s good too_)You could almost cut Grevious and related stuff out of the Movie Entirely, For all you know Grevious Could be the Trade Federation Guy
5 I would Cut that robot talking guy with the Vader Voice too, Real Cheesy
6 I coulda used just a little more Palpatine pulling the strings but I have nothing specific in mind other than the Maul Palpy Scene from EPI
7 Palpys face after the Windu Fight, Wish there was a way to fix that face, what were they thinking!
8 The Choke/Force Push on Padame… Wish he just threw her or something to make it more beliveable her injuries are life threatening. Or just have him choke her out hard
9 And Just an Idea I’ve wanted to incorporate into my edit is calling them clone droids in the title crawl and having kenobi call it a clone droid factory.
10 A dream perhaps… Recolor and redub Jango as Boba
11 Noticed some studder on the Deleted Scene of the senetors forming the rebelion spoiler