Hal 9000 said:
Also, are we sure we don’t like the Russian version of the Vader scream? 😛I believe that you might be the only one who wants to keep Vader screaming “No !!!” and the Frankenstein’s Monster walk as well. Are you sur you don’t like the L8 version of the scene ? 😃
I’ve given my reasons numerous times. It’s not that I want to, as much as feel I need to.
I might agree about L8wrtr’s wipe mid-scene, except that I feel he didn’t implement it very well. Considering that your primary goal is to make the edit feel as professionally edited as possible (which I have said many times to multiple people, that the best fan edits don’t appear fan-made), I can understand why you would leave it in if your efforts to remove it make it feel obvious there was a cut there.
Of course, I say that, and mid-sentence I think about the scene in ANH at the Death Star conference room where Vader waves his hand as though David Prowse is continuing even though Vader has no speaking part.