logo Sign In

Post #757951

Author
metalmunki
Parent topic
The Unofficial Complete REVISITED SAGA Ideas and Random Discussion Thread
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/757951/action/topic#757951
Date created
18-Mar-2015, 8:51 AM

I'll address both of you in this post just because .Mac stated he agreed with everything metalmunki said.[...]

That's some Sith-like/Iraq war-like thinking there. You think the Alliance would happily go full-force on a heavily populated world? It's not all Stormtroopers down there, you know. The Alliance attacks *military* targets. They are out and out good-guys (this is pulp/family entertainment after all not a gritty war drama). Coruscant itself is a hearts and minds campaign if anything,and the ending ROTJ montage justifies that.

No, just no.

ROTJ has its problems (We could've done with the forest coming alive to indirectly help kill the STs rather than just Ewoks, for example), but wholesale changing plot and location is just too far. ROTJ still has to be ROTJ.