logo Sign In

Post #594493

Author
GeoMFilms
Parent topic
STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"ADYWAN - 12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/594493/action/topic#594493
Date created
8-Sep-2012, 10:21 PM

Ziz said:



GeoMFilms said:

I've never seen the full updated A New Hope but if there is a way to use the Vader suit to add a scene for ANH then It would be great to add a scene where Vader finds out the name of the pilot that destroyed the death star.

You could add a scene right after luke,han and leia walk away from the x-wing celebrating but before the ceremony. Have a scene of Vaders tie fighter landing in the docking bay of a near by star destroyer.

in that scene vader could be told what the name of the pilot who destroyed the death star is.

Hated the fact that vader finds out he has a child off screen. (For those who will watch the old trilogy first they will just think Vader is shocked to her the name Luke SKYWALKER because Vader 'betrayed and Murdered your father'. They will think Vader is thinking of Luke's Father that he had killed (but we know that lukes father....is...VADER nooooooooooo)


 

NO.

It's no stretch of the imagination to think that some Imperial operative found out who destroyed the Death Star and got word back to Vader at some point.  We don't need to see it happen to know it did.

The reason "I am your father!" worked so well in 1980 was BECAUSE you didn't see it coming.  Obi-Wan's explanation of it in ROTJ forced you to realize that the world/galaxy isn't as linear and straightforward as you thought it was.

The biggest problem with the PT (and Lucas' changes to the OT, and films today in general) is that they're spoon-feeding the audience every last detail before it's needed.  In effect, they're spoiling the end of the movie IN the movie!

Part of what makes a good film good is that you're going along WITH one or more of the characters trying to figure out what's going on.  If you have all the necessary information ahead of time, it kills all the mystery and suspense.  Watching the film becomes a passive experience rather than an active one.


Well if a scene like that was ever made that doesn't spoil the end of ESB where Vader tells luke he is his Father.

If in the scene if an officer tells Vader the name of the pilot is Luke SKYWALKER. People who watch the OT first will just think "ohhh i bet Vader is shocked to hear that name because 'Vader betrayed and murdered' Lukes father.

But those who know he is Luke's father already will know that Vader is shocked to hear that name because for the first time he will realize that Padme DID give birth.

The WHOLE saga shows us different IMPORTANT parts of Anakins/Vader life. (Being freed as slave, meeting the Jedi, getting married, turns into Vader, finds out Padme is dead, tells Luke he is his father, and redeemed himself at end)

Finding out he has a son is the first turning point in Vaders life. Thats a BIG event. That would be something that would be seen on screen.

We know in ESB that Vader is looking for 'Skywalker'. That didn't ruin the end of ESB just because he was already looking for Skywalker.

If done right that in my mind would be a great addition.