Rob said:

msycamore said:

Ok, I thought that would be the case. You're right of course, you tend to be overly critical when you know what flaws to look for, as a complete film experience these versions you make will certainly be fantastic for most viewers, don't let my comments dampen your spirit, I'm just a stubborn purist. What you're able to achieve here is quite awesome.

I've watched Harmy's ESB close to 20 times in the last couple of weeks, and if you're not satisfied with that masterpiece, you're not going to be satisfied with anything short of perfection (which we'll never see). We've all waited nearly forever for the Original Trilogy, and now thanks to Harmy, we'll have it. Harmy's cuts are so damn good, I think they're the first versions that are above nitpicking. They're so beautiful I'm not going to waste my time searching for flaws.

I can admit that I came off like a dick in my earlier statement in this thread (but you like di*** Rob, don't you ;) when I read it again and it was unnecessary and stupid of me and for that I'm sorry Harmy. But the post I made that you quote here, I don't see any problem with, I thought the test-clips he uploaded here was meant to be scrutinized and to give him some feedback on how to maybe improve upon them (it can be argued however if my feedback on the mos eisley clip was constructive or not).