vaderios said:

DarthJarJar said:

I like my Dagobah gloomy. I like vignettes and I like mattes. I don't mind if they look like they are painted. Sometimes I like them BECAUSE they look like paintings. Great paintings.

That's not to say I don't like Adys changes. I loved ANH:R and I am excited about all the changes in ESB:R. I just wanted to say that I have a love of the old fashioned arts of movie making.

Ady released a pre SE version of ESB ;) Its full of the stuff you like in the best quality available. You can check it ;) There you will find "your dagobah"

-Angel

As I said, I like the stuff Ady has done. IN ANH:R he enhanced some mattes but they are still there. He revisited with a light touch. Even when he did cut loose with his big changes (DS reveal and the battle of Yavin) I felt he was spot on (particularly the battle which is now epic).

In ESB I love some of the SE stuff, such as the windows in cloud city but I hate the vader shuttle sequence / Boba Fett's voice and the Emperor's dialogue. It looks like Ady is removing/fixing all these but keeping the stuff I like and giving it a polish too. The best of both worlds.