logo Sign In

Post #1183668

Author
ChainsawAsh
Parent topic
The Last Jedi: Official Review and Opinions Thread ** SPOILERS **
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1183668/action/topic#1183668
Date created
16-Mar-2018, 6:05 PM

Creox said:

SilverWook said:

Matt.F said:

SilverWook said:

Sure! If you have a 100 inch screen in your house. šŸ˜›

Iā€™m surprised to read a dismissive comment about 4K on this site. I thought OT forum was very much built around wanting the very best ā€˜technicalā€™ presentation of Star Wars, from sound, to accurate colour representation, to resolution - arenā€™t these technical aspects fundamental to Originaltrilogy.com? Or do forum members actually not care that much?

I care, but 4K for home use is primarily a scheme to get me to buy a new 4K tv, a new 4K player, a new 4K ready receiver, etc. Half of whatā€™s on the format is simply upscaled from 2K. Pixar doesnā€™t even render their films at 4K.
https://twitter.com/leeunkrich/status/966464478937153536
And donā€™t even get me started on 30 year old movies with questionable Atmos remixes and no original mix option in sight. Iā€™m not about to drill holes in the ceiling of a 40 year old house to put Atmos speakers above me, either.
The displays Iā€™ve seen in stores look very nice, but they just donā€™t look like film to me. I imagine a lot of crap in the tv has to be switched off to get a film like image though.

When a restored non buggered OOT is on 4k, wake me. 2001 and The Shining might get me to budge as well. I am getting a bit long in the tooth to consider rebuying all my favorite movies again on a for a third time.
Thankfully, Iā€™ll probably be too old to care when 8K comes along. šŸ˜‰

I was glad to see your comments of 4K not looking like film. I agree. Many films or TV programs Iā€™ve seen in 4K have the soap opera look to itā€¦kinds like 60 fps with LOTR did for me.

Thatā€™s the TV with all its motion interpolation and other image processing turned on, not the 4K source material. Turn all that shit off and turn your sharpness down to zero and itā€™ll look like film, as long as itā€™s a good transfer/master. But the soap opera effect is 100% the TVā€™s motion interpolation.