She abandoned the order before RotS by the way, and only because the order abandoned her first. And she was in the epilogue ICYMI, and I think the epilogue is set arount the time of RotJ, and she was doing just fine. I don’t think that she being trapped in Malachor is an excuse for her apparent uselessness during the OT either.

And I believe I had the same argument I was about to have with you in regards to your last paragraph in the TLJ thread with someone else. I don’t think it’s comparable. Not only that, but the point is that Yoda should’ve felt Ahsoka and told Luke something about her, and he clearly trusted her.

Now giving it some more thought, maybe she’d compromise Luke’s mission by giving him crucial information that Yoda didn’t want him to know, or something like that.

But I still think it’s bullshit - and I find it hard to believe that Ahsoka wouldn’t look for Luke after hearing that he was friends with Obi-Wan.

Ah, so many plot holes. Why not just kill her at the end of S2? It would’ve been much more powerful.