logo Sign In

Post #1158736

Author
Warbler
Parent topic
The Last Jedi: Official Review and Opinions Thread ** SPOILERS **
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1158736/action/topic#1158736
Date created
16-Jan-2018, 3:49 PM

dahmage said:

Warbler said:

So tell me something, just who was Luke’s equal in the dark side in the OT? As one rises in one side of the force, another rises on the opposite side, right? It couldn’t have been Vader, he rose to power a lot early in the PT and he didn’t get more powerful as Luke got more powerful. Also if that idea is true, there should have been a lot more dark jedis around during the PT, one for every jedi.

not really. I understood that line to have more to do with their being no existing light side users for the force to balance against, so it all manifested in one place. If Luke wasn’t cut off from the force, i think things would have been different.

that is not how I read it all.

Also, its all made up stuff anyway.

I’m sorry, but there is no reason to say this.

  1. we all know that

  2. that could excuse any continuity error/plot hole in any fiction.

  3. it being true, doesn’t mean the fiction universe shouldn’t make sense.

  4. its lame to say it

In ESB, Obiwan says that if Luke goes to face Vader he will face him alone, “I can not help you”. But look what Yoda did in TLJ. Sure seems like Obiwan could have lent a hand now.

different people. different circumstances.

um no, same universe. same force. Either force ghosts can do what Yoda can do in TLJ or they can’t. Unless you the movie explains how the force somehow changed and now force ghosts can do things they couldn’t do before. But no explanation was giving.

Also, all made up.

read what I wrote above about that.