logo Sign In

TFA: A Gentle Restructure (Released) — Page 49

Author
Time

The first couple transitions work well. The third is rough, as you say, but honestly shouldn’t be terribly hard to smooth out (it’s really the music build-up fake out that kills it, if you cut out the music through the transition it should work better).

As for the idea itself, I like it, but I worry that it might not work so well in practice. Since it’s never stated outright, I think the fact that the Starkiller has two potential targets might lean more towards confusing than suspenseful. I still feel like practically speaking that Republic first, then they turn to the Resistance might work better.

Author
Time

This current idea is pretty eloquent which could be pretty smooth if the transitions are smoothed out, slightly. When I watched those it wasn’t too jarring. Just edit some sounds/music and it could work fine. Even some transition wipes would work too.

I do like the goal of this project idea to have the base fire once. The resistance both succeeded and failed at the end at the same time.

As another edit, maybe Never’s starlight project would be a good fit for it.

“Because you are a PalpaWalker?”

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Here’s an idea: cut back to the Resistance planning room right after Snoke says “Bring her to me.” Since they’ve just been talking about the reconnaissance ship and the Resistance Base, it makes a lot of sense. Then after the Han/Leia farewell scene show the establishing shot of the TIE’s over the the Starkiller Base mountains from earlier (where I assume it’s been deleted in favor of the planetary establishing shot), then cut to Rey’s mind trick scene. This also gives Rey more time to figure out how to mind trick the guard and less time aimlessly wandering around the base.

@Dominic: I think sometimes we worry too much about confusing the audience. I know I do 😉 But the plan before the reconnaissance ship was to destroy the Republic, so it’s pretty clear that it’s still in their crosshairs.

You probably don’t recognize me because of the red arm.
Episode 9 Rewrite, The Starlight Project (Released!) and ANH Technicolor Project (Released!)

Author
Time

NeverarGreat said:

Here’s an idea: cut back to the Resistance planning room right after Snoke says “Bring her to me.” Since they’ve just been talking about the reconnaissance ship and the Resistance Base, it makes a lot of sense. Then after the Han/Leia farewell scene show the establishing shot of the TIE’s over the the Starkiller Base mountains from earlier (where I assume it’s been deleted in favor of the planetary establishing shot), then cut to Rey’s mind trick scene. This also gives Rey more time to figure out how to mind trick the guard and less time aimlessly wandering around the base.

Ohhhh, that sounds like it flows better based on the conversations of characters.

“Because you are a PalpaWalker?”

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Hmmmm… that’s not really much better. Poe starts talking immediately, so I’m afraid it’s going to feel less than ideal to transition into that scene from any other than the weapon charging scene. (The audio at the end of that scene is the same audio that transitions into that scene originally.)
I’d say, “Oh, well,” but you bring up a good point that the First Order probably should express awareness of the Resistance base’s location at some point.

My stance on revising fan edits.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Here’s the sequence I’m looking at:

Resistance Base
Weapon Charging
Battle Plans
Farewell
Rey’s Interrogation
Snoke
Rey Escapes
Landing at Hyperspace

Since the bolded sections must stay together, Rey’s interrogation must fall on one side of them or the other. I feel like we’re away from her almost too long in the Theatrical version, so at least part of the interrogation should happen before the weapon charging. However, since Snoke’s scene should happen after the charging, there’s no natural way to include her in this section of the film. That’s a problem if Rey’s still supposed to be the main character.

So either the bolded section must be split somehow, or Rey’s interrogation must be split into two sections, with one before the bolded section.

Here’s an old mockup of how such a split could happen, just disregard the sequence: https://vimeo.com/214598035
Password: learning

You probably don’t recognize me because of the red arm.
Episode 9 Rewrite, The Starlight Project (Released!) and ANH Technicolor Project (Released!)

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Hmmm… that ordering is probably the least problematic way to include the Republic/Resistance tension you brought up, though I share your reservations about it, but it might be okay to be away from Rey for a while if it sidesteps the other problems.

Meanwhile, here’s an earnest attempt at an earlier, alternate solution to this problem:
https://vimeo.com/244748972
password: snoke

JEDIT: NeverarGreat, that clip contains some interesting ideas. I like how you have Rey gradually discover her abilities, and build tension as Kylo Ren stomps toward her cell.

My stance on revising fan edits.

Author
Time

Neverar - Very fascinating concept of breaking things up. The mockup video had some good ideas and I would agree with Hal its ok to be away from Rey a bit. Hmmmm. Obviously from your list and parts of the mockup video one of the obvious issues is the who helmet and pacing for Ren being off and on like crazy. 😉

For Hal, that alternate solution can work since it now gives a reason to target the resistance since their main objective has been completed … time for the next one.

“Because you are a PalpaWalker?”

Author
Time

The clip I just posted is about as good as that can be pulled off (by me, at present). Treat it as a candidate for a final product, not a mockup. (I.e., if it doesn’t sound or feel right, let me know.)

My stance on revising fan edits.

Author
Time

Hal 9000 said:

Meanwhile, here’s an earnest attempt at an earlier, alternate solution to this problem:
https://vimeo.com/244748972
password: snoke

I honestly think this would be a lot better (though I think the transitions need some work).

In terms of the other way around, I think your initial mock up from earlier today is still the best way to go about it (though the audio on that third transition would need minor adjustments).

If you feel like you need help with either in terms of smoothing transitions, that might be something I could help with (to be clear, I’d rather not, just because I’m a little busy in general and I know you guys want this out soon, but I will help if needed).

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Hal 9000 said:

I am leaning toward this ‘alternate, older’ solution, so I’d say hold off an doing work yourself unless we determine it’s that route or bust.

To be clear, I agree the older solution is better, but I think the clip you just posted needs work too.

Author
Time
 (Edited)

First of all, good job on the scene, it’s as good as I could imagine it getting with the resources at our disposal.

However, the reason I abandoned that short Snoke scene was because there were too many weird things about it, such as the complete lack of acknowledgement about the Republic’s destruction, further keeping Snoke in the dark about First Order information (when were they going to tell him about that reconnaissance ship?!), and the brevity of the scene makes it seem too perfunctory and ad hoc. It’s certainly serviceable though, so it’s better than nothing if it comes to that.

JEDIT:
I’m glad people like the Starlight mockups. I’m a big fan of keeping the focus on Rey as much as possible, and trying to imply that she’s learning over an extended period of time through Ren’s interrogations. Even though the discussion has moved on a bit, I had made this mockup just this morning:
https://vimeo.com/244699807
Password: rey

This follows the sequence:
Resistance Base
Weapon Charging
Interrogations
Snoke (reconnaissance tracking)
Failed Mind Trick
Battle Plans
Farewells
Successful Mind Trick
Landing from Hyperspace

Of course, the necessity of keeping the charging-Battle Plans connection renders this rather moot.

You probably don’t recognize me because of the red arm.
Episode 9 Rewrite, The Starlight Project (Released!) and ANH Technicolor Project (Released!)

Author
Time
 (Edited)

I love the last two edited scenes posted here. I agree the video transition could be smoother (maybe slowing down the final shot of “I will tighter your restraints” could do the trick ?) but even without being perfect they decrease some plot issues. It’s worth the effort I think ! (take your time to polish it guys, no hurry to release it before TLJ)

edit: I would even suggest to remove the “And I will drop my weapon” which is out of place in the dramatic flow of the movie at this point (TFA is often too “bad comedy-oriented”, decreasing this aspect could be the work of another edit though).

Author
Time

Neverar I like that mock up a lot!

“Because you are a PalpaWalker?”

Author
Time
 (Edited)

Hal 9000 said:

Hmmm… that ordering is probably the least problematic way to include the Republic/Resistance tension you brought up, though I share your reservations about it, but it might be okay to be away from Rey for a while if it sidesteps the other problems.

Meanwhile, here’s an earnest attempt at an earlier, alternate solution to this problem:
https://vimeo.com/244748972
password: snoke

I don’t know. That seems to have Ren getting from A to B to C almost unrealistically quickly. Granted some amount of time could occur between cuts, but the music doesn’t even change so the scenes flow together suggesting they’re relatively close timewise.

TV’s Frink said:

chyron just put a big Ric pic in your sig and be done with it.

Author
Time

The scene in the original version is actually shorter, so it really comes down to the music tying it together. It really needs a final note when Rey and Finn exit the oscillator, and a beat before Snoke starts talking. I think that would make it sound like there was more of a time difference between the scenes.

You probably don’t recognize me because of the red arm.
Episode 9 Rewrite, The Starlight Project (Released!) and ANH Technicolor Project (Released!)

Author
Time
 (Edited)

If everyone’s okay with being away from Rey for a while, the scene reordering becomes more simple:

Resistance Base
Weapon Charging
Battle Plans
Farewells
Interrogation
Snoke

Not knowing what’s happening with Kylo and Rey may be a good thing, since the focus would be on Finn and his plan to get Rey. As it is, Finn concocts a desperate plan to save Rey when we know she’s already escaped and is in the process of finding a ship to escape.

So if we wanted to make this a more dramatic rescue (Read: ignore because I get carried away), the next scenes could play out like this:

Snoke
Landing at Lightspeed
Rey’s Failed Mind Trick
Lowering the Shields
Preparing to Storm the Detention Block (ending with “Are you sure you’re ready for this?” “Hell no.”)
Rey’s Escape
Hangars on Lockdown
Rejoining Rey

You probably don’t recognize me because of the red arm.
Episode 9 Rewrite, The Starlight Project (Released!) and ANH Technicolor Project (Released!)

Author
Time

It would keep us from bouncing around by your current idea.

“Because you are a PalpaWalker?”

Author
Time

Hal 9000 said:

Hmmm… that ordering is probably the least problematic way to include the Republic/Resistance tension you brought up, though I share your reservations about it, but it might be okay to be away from Rey for a while if it sidesteps the other problems.

Meanwhile, here’s an earnest attempt at an earlier, alternate solution to this problem:
https://vimeo.com/244748972
password: snoke

JEDIT: NeverarGreat, that clip contains some interesting ideas. I like how you have Rey gradually discover her abilities, and build tension as Kylo Ren stomps toward her cell.

This looks good, with the exception of the audio transition into the Snoke scene sounding pretty rough.

Author
Time

NeverarGreat said:

JEDIT:
I’m glad people like the Starlight mockups. I’m a big fan of keeping the focus on Rey as much as possible, and trying to imply that she’s learning over an extended period of time through Ren’s interrogations. Even though the discussion has moved on a bit, I had made this mockup just this morning:
https://vimeo.com/244699807
Password: rey

I feel like the transition from the first Rey scene to the briefing room is too quick for a wipe. It would honestly be better as a straight cut. Personally, I think the wipes really only work well with establishing shots and long takes, where they can really luxuriate.

Author
Time

Octorox said:

NeverarGreat said:

JEDIT:
I’m glad people like the Starlight mockups. I’m a big fan of keeping the focus on Rey as much as possible, and trying to imply that she’s learning over an extended period of time through Ren’s interrogations. Even though the discussion has moved on a bit, I had made this mockup just this morning:
https://vimeo.com/244699807
Password: rey

I feel like the transition from the first Rey scene to the briefing room is too quick for a wipe. It would honestly be better as a straight cut. Personally, I think the wipes really only work well with establishing shots and long takes, where they can really luxuriate.

Yep, overuse of wipes is one of my biggest pet peeves in SW fan edits (and with theatrical Episodes II and III).

Though I’ll also say that I think theatrical TFA underused them, but that’s another story. They only really belong when there’s a passage of time or a drastic change in location (as in, not from outdoors to indoors, as an example).

Author
Time

The thing about these is each is as long as the source material will allow, and I could only shorten them from here. I can try using the TIE mountain establishing shot and see how that plays.

My stance on revising fan edits.