logo Sign In

Post #1135162

Author
Shopping Maul
Parent topic
My thoughts on various changes
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1135162/action/topic#1135162
Date created
26-Nov-2017, 1:37 AM

Vader did it to save his son, not to “kill the bad guy”. There’s a big difference there.

But that just makes Vader’s motives more selfish. Palpatine was slaughtering people by the shipload (not to mention subjugating an entire galaxy). You’d think Luke would be justified in taking this guy down. But no, all Luke could do was make sure he stayed Zen. Great if you’re scoring brownie points at a Buddhist retreat maybe, but not much help with the war effort.
Vader’s position was purely selfish. “Hey, no-one messes with my kid!”. He was merely protecting his own. How does this earn him instant Jedi nirvana?