The established canon for the Kelvin “timeline” is that it is in fact actually an entirely different alternate reality:
That is not the way it appears in Star Trek 2009.
That is exactly how it appeared and was intended to appear.
That is not the meaning I got out of Star Trek 2009.
I don’t understand how you could possibly take that meaning from it.
Don’t they say that in the film, literally calling it an “alternate reality?”