I do not want to put any kind of cut scenes list because that will RUIN everything.
That’s kind of a standard thing for fan edits. Very few people will want to commit to watching hours upon hours of edits of films they’ve seen multiple times in many forms, official and fan edited, without a cutlist.
I know I won’t, especially after I’ve already seen about 5-10 fan edits of each prequel and have finally settled on the ones I like the most.
Well then only you lose in this situation. I’ve never watched anyone else’s except the two phantom edits - and they were just so so. Removing JarJar doesn’t fix the movie - and those two edits failed to FIX the movies. Changing Jar Jar voice and giving him proper eng subs ‘fixes’ his character. If he’s not a total moron then you do;t hate him - and he has CRUCIAL moments in the story. In a perfect world, he’d have his own eng style proper voice and not mesa wesa yousa…for now, it’s subtitles.
The only way to fix AOTC is to gather everything off the cutting room floor. AOTC is the most poorly edited film I’ve ever seen. The heart and soul are LITERALLY on the cutting room floor. That’s just sad and shameful. Professional people made that movie, people long time in the industry. WOW.
So I didn’t watch anyone’s - I just made my my own. I think I’ve done the overall story justice. I get that you don’t want to check it out without a list telling you EVERYTHING I’ve done and thus ruining the experience but that’s your call, completely. Like I said though - only you lose in that situation. But thanks for coming here to tell me you wont watch it. Instead of just wasting your time (apparently with my edits) now you’ve wasted BOTH of ours. lol 😉
All good but I’ve been working on these for two years. I wouldn’t come in here with crap - I’m pretty confident these are VERY good - I wouldn’t do that people. I don’t think anything else can be fixed story wise in my edits (that I can do, I didn’t get paid for this). Editing previously time, scored and edited footage is not not easy. It’s hard to get in and out of scenes like you’d like too - so I’m confident in them. Others may look prettier lol but I’m just concentrating on the story. I know it’s along haul - 9 movies - but I hope it’s worth it. You have to watch them all, that’s the thing. I tried to make that way (again, hopefully).
Hopefully you change your mind one day…or maybe I’ll try and come up with some kind of changes list. Ugh, I should have done it while I watched them all again last weekend… “We shall see…we shall see…”
Oh if any one wants to see a sample of a rough cut scene I added to Force Awakens (maybe to get a taste) go youtube ‘SNOKE DELETED SCENE’, look for ‘Dj Ritty’ beside it and click that (it’s got 290K views I think). It’s an early rough cut cuz everything i’ve put up after gets deleted.