After hearing you say it is more of a blueprint than a truly polished edit, I will hold back some of my complaints. It is a bit rough, but I find using what I believe is the Hindi audio for Jar Jar to be inspired. You didn’t actually change the meaning of his dialog, but just the different voice made a big difference. I have only watched the first part of TPM, AOTC, and Clone Wars, but your edits are clearly an improvement. But you really do need a better audio source for Jar Jar’s lines. The one you used is kind of jarring at times. And you really need to replace everything Jar Jar says, not just his main dialog. But your edit of Kenobi and Skywalker’s dialog when they meet Padme in ATOC is right in line with what I’ve been thinking that scene needed. The master/padawan relationship shouldn’t take away from their friendship like it does in the theatrical cut.
THANK YOU. The hindi track is the problem. NO source is good. It’s like they recorded it over the actual movie lol No it’s BAD. That is not my fault and nothing I could do about it. It sucks because it’s the first part so that can a negative perspective on things to come. I’ve watched these so many times it doesn’t bother me too much but there’s simply nothing I can do. I have to fix Boss Nass’ dialogue with guigon to remove the audio pops but again - the dub was SO lousy it just it is what is.
Thanks again. Please dl the newer links - TPM had about 10 edits I had to redo and the other films all had about 5 or less.
But honestly feel feel to mention anything else you thought didn’t work. I can only judge from my point of view - I need to see what others think too. 😉