logo Sign In

Post #1097624

Author
Ronster
Parent topic
STAR WARS: EP V "REVISITED EDITION"ADYWAN - 12GB 1080p MP4 VERSION AVAILABLE NOW
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1097624/action/topic#1097624
Date created
13-Aug-2017, 3:07 PM

I will give you some feedback on a few shots… I don’t think there is anything particularly wrong with the work I think it has more to do with the source that you are using.

These a small things but in a sea of outstanding let’s nail this down and it’s not about pointing fingers or personal opinion.

ok first.

Pink legs became just bright legs. In terms of matching this up the legs need to be darker but it’s no big deal.

This sort of Fluro Jumpsuit in this part of the film only must be something to do with brightness and recomp in the blu-ray. Where ever the recomps are you need to compensate for the increased boost in the source. But when the jumpsuit like this It looks wrong it’s probably about 4 shots total that it goes this color in Hoth battle seemed pretty good the rest of the film. But this was extreme but again it’s the video source suddenly changing most likely and your LUT not compensating.

Here you have been caught out by how bad a shot this is in every version on home video but… Outside the window is fine it’s on another layer.

Inside you have the weird purple magenta tint from the original still happening which is a huge way out shot compared to the rest of the film. Here is my reference.

Basically the highlights are a big problem but I do believe this particular shot tints yellow to be right in the highlights at least for the interior.

Finally

I still think the ground lacks detail in this shot and it’s again the video source it’s just got something wrong with it and it’s not your fault. In terms of finding a replacement I can point you here to fix the ground detail on this shot only as all the rest are ok.
https://youtu.be/DYldBHQw3s4?t=73

Would not be the first time you nicked shots from stargate… Keep the tradition going! 😃 That really is all I have to say Not trying to push ideas but I do think that shot with the ground lacks detail and I know it’s not your fault so no bother leave it if you want to. But apart from that. I don’t think I have any points to raise and this was constructive criticism and I don’t think it is crucial or very demanding in any sense but this was if you like what I can see and perhaps just an opinion.

Shock Horror my favourite edit… A splash by you know who in the swamp. Surprised?