iamweasel said:
What do you guys think?

Well, I think that Rogue One is, by far and without contest, the worst Star Wars ever, so I wouldn’t want this awful movie as Episode III. And I really like Episode III the way it was released in theater (even if I prefer solid fanedits of it to remove the little bits I don’t like). Even Episode II is way better than Rogue One (!). And even with not perfect movies I like the “2 trilogies” structure developed by Lucas with his 6 movies saga, something you would completely lose by cutting down them to 5 movies with the terrible (which doesn’t add anything of value) Rogue One inserted into it.