JEDIT @ Val:
I noticed the lack of clouds in the second Star Destroyer shot as well, but it’s like that in the original film. I suppose I could add some more clouds to the second shot…it’s something to consider.
As for the R2 scenes, it’s a delicate line between being too obvious and making the audience wonder why nobody noticed the blinking lights and making it too subtle and having people miss it. I opted for subtlety, since people bothered by the conveniences would probably be more observant anyway. My brother suggested a slow zoom in to the panel. That could work.
I also agree with you about the fanedit info, but it’s not a big deal for me either way.
Ah ok, so it’s an inconsistency in the theatrical cut itself? Interesting, can’t say I noticed it before but then I’ve only seen the theatrical once or twice and perusing fan edit WIPs does tend to hone your attention to details such as these 😛 If that’s the case then maybe it’s not worth bothering with especially in regards to Hal’s mission regarding the edit.
I know what you mean regarding R2, along with the sound effects I think it is obvious enough. I think a slow zoom would be far too obvious, might as well place a big arrow pointing to it 😛 Though if it was only a very slight zoom that just “nudges” the viewer’s attention to that place in the image so they can’t help but notice the lights, then it might work…hard to decide without seeing it in action I guess.
I agree the fan edit info is not a huge deal but just something I wanted to mention / ask about.
.Val