I’d have to see it but the combination of a shuttle flying directly at them and a surprise attack is what feels off to me. Not having the Stardestroyer wouldn’t change that and also it looks very cool.
With the material available I’d say something bad has to come directly at them, and TIEs need to fly over Rey. I don’t know if the way the crowd is looking and where Rey is is even the same, so perhaps seeing TIEs in both places would technically be two different groups of TIEs which would explain why they don’t match exactly, but would raise other questions. Hmmm.
Something else to try could be changing the shot where Rey looks up to have the TIEs a bit higher up.