logo Sign In

Post #1021660

Author
timdiggerm
Parent topic
Rogue Zero - What was changed, reshot, etc in Rogue One?
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/1021660/action/topic#1021660
Date created
20-Dec-2016, 12:46 PM

DominicCobb said:

timdiggerm said:

Yavin changes are the very next thing I want to add to the top-posts - but it feels like a huge muddle. I have a lot of questions.

Do we even know that Jyn was going to start the movie imprisoned?

Start not necessarily but certainly she ends up on Yavin in cuffs.

Very good point. Not sure how that works with Jedha before Yavin. Hm.

Where does the missing rebel starfighter strike on Jedha fit? (Its excision, btw, may be related to inserting the Eadu sequence, if we think that’s totally reshoots)

Do we know there was a missing strike on Jedha? Where does that come from? As for Eadu, it’s possible there could have been a sequence there beforehand but it would have been completely different. My biggest question mark is where Galen fits into all of this pre-reshoots.

See my links here, but I guess we don’t know. Agree about Galen pre-reshoots being a mystery.

Rebel Command know there’s a weapon being built, and it’s going to be tested soon. Is that test still Jedha? I assume so, but then we have the Death Star starting at Scerif (its construction site), then heading to Jedha, then returning to Scerif.

Since Jyn doesn’t learn about the Death Star until she’s at Yavin post-Jedha, what does she think is going on on Jedha with Saw, Bohdi, Cassian, etc?

I think the sequencing of things aren’t too different from the theatrical. Jyn is on Jedha with Saw beforehand via flashbacks, but the sequence with Cassian, Bodhi, K2, etc. doesn’t happen until after Yavin. It was still their first stop, and probably for similar reasons.

I may be coming around to your view on this order of events.

As for the Death Star, who knows.