logo Sign In

Post #458301

Author
haljordan28
Parent topic
anothe example of lucas changing things to appeal to a new generation lightsaber dueling styles of OT vs PT
Link to post in topic
https://originaltrilogy.com/post/id/458301/action/topic#458301
Date created
18-Dec-2010, 4:18 PM

Anyone ever wonder why lucas changed the dueling styles from the OT way to the  PT way.

 

Lucas claims   ..at least this is what he says NOW. that the jedi  fought that way in the OT  bnecause   vader was  weak and  a machine  and luke was untrained  and ben was an old man  and that the jedi in PT  were in their prime and    fought  flashy  because of that.  well this is another example of lucas blowing smoke up  ppls  ass;s  and here is why

 

for one the whole ben was an old man argument   maskles no sense..yoda  was old  dooku was old..   that didnt stop them  from jumpoing around like ninja turltes..... general grivious  was all machine just abiout and it didnt stop him.....the  youngling  in  epuisoide 3  was  young and mostly untrained and he  looked like a  ninja turtle also...this is all mopre  LUCAS  biullshit trying to  excusxe   his prequel   junk...

 

heres the facts on the  dueling styles....ion the OT  era..lucas always  claimed that the jedi were a mix of   merlin the wizard and the knights of the round table.....hence him using old europeon  style  swod fighting....the same style sword fighting you  find  in  braveheart, gladiator, lord of the rings,  hifglander..etc..etc   and that style  was befitting of a jedi knight....

 

enter the  junkquels,,,,think about  what was popular  at this time..martial arts,  ninjas, pokemon,  yugi oh..etc..etc   lucas  changed the  dueling style to  eastern based martial arts style.     the   saber duels in the pt  looks just like sword fighting in any NINJA film or  samuari film. sure its pretty and it looks good  and i actually like it in martial arts films  but   not for star wars. it  looks  cherograhped and rehearsed.  there is nothing  real about it.

the  dueling in the OT has a sense of realsim to it.  in episode  5  when luke appraches  vader   he ignites his lightsaber...and takes a swing...vader blocks it calmpy...luke takes a step towards vader...vader   slowly  tkes a step  back  in a defensive  move....   if this had been the prequels  luke would have  done a back flip up the steps and  spinned around  4  times before even swinging on vader....vader would have done three  flips and spins  and twirlled his saber around    5 times   before  striking back at luke.

everything about the prequels is so  pathetic and fans of the PT   wonder why  we  real fans  of star wars who fight to defend it   feel this way?

 

ill never stop bashing the prequels  and ill never stop defending the  real editions of the OT. and i do quote  people like gary lurtz  and  marcia lucas  and  and many other peoiple you wont find mentioned at starwars.com because  these people hold on to the truth  and they tell the truth  cause we sure cant depend on lucas or lucasfilm to do it

 

and  pt fans  accuse me and others here of bashing lucas when we call him a lier.  sorry but  we just tell the truth and if many of you pt  fans would bother to research it  and dig up his old interviews  you would see    where he has lied. more times than I can count  but  you pt  fans are not interested in the truth.  you  want to ignore it and act like it never happend.  I and many others my age were lucky enough to grow up in that time perioed and we heard the truth and read the truth.   i bought every starlog mag i could   with star wars interviews growing up.  i held on to every word from lucas cause back then i worshiped the man as did many others here.  uo till he turned his back not only on us the fans but on star wars its self and pimped out the name  for  profit.  thats the only   satisfaction i get from the prequels is knowing lucas   ruined his legacy with them.