The OT.com J. R. R. Tolkien & Middle Earth Discussion Thread :: 1 < 3

  • Reply
  • Print
skyjedi2005's avatar
RE: The OT.com J. R. R. Tolkien & Middle Earth Discussion Thread

Tolkien's Fall of Arthur will be published this year and i highly doubted it would ever happen.  Now if only the longer Beren and Luthien can be published or his renderings of Beowulf and Commentaries.

I still have to pick up his longer originally unpublished on fairy stories essay published in the united kingdom but not the US.

Also hoping his beowulf and the Critics essay not the shorter version gets reprinted.

Was really disappointing that the audiobook version of Sigurd and Gudrun never came out despite the trailer i have the book and it is quite good.

Already have read the entirely of the history of middle earth, unfinished tales, Children Of Hurin, history of the hobbit etc. Makes me wonder what other manuscripts are yet to be discovered by Christopher Tolkien,lol.

Last edited on March 17, 2013 at 8:44 AM by skyjedi2005

 "Always loved Vader's wordless self sacrifice. Another shitty, clueless, revision like Greedo and young Anakin's ghost. What a fucking shame." -Simon Pegg.

doubleofive's avatar
RE: The OT.com J. R. R. Tolkien & Middle Earth Discussion Thread

I'm with you AK. I'm glad I waited, but it doesn't seem as INCREDIBLE. I will withhold judgment until I have it in hand though.

Star Wars Revisited Wordpress / Google+ / Facebook / Twitter

Cinetropolis - My new movie blog home

Where to hear me online

Mithrandir's avatar
RE: The OT.com J. R. R. Tolkien & Middle Earth Discussion Thread

I wander why Dale has a bigger visual scale than Minas Tirith... similar to what happened with the PT technology being more advanced than the OT in star wars...

Or Erebor being greater or richer than Moria...mithril!

emanswfan's avatar
RE: The OT.com J. R. R. Tolkien & Middle Earth Discussion Thread

Well, atleast the 2D EE Bluray cover art is much better than what we got on the 2D theatrical.

fishmanlee's avatar
RE: The OT.com J. R. R. Tolkien & Middle Earth Discussion Thread

Mithrandir said:

or richer than Moria...mithril!

Erebor in glory vs. Moria in Decline....

The reason the EE is so short, is because the Theatrical is so long.

Last edited on August 2, 2013 at 11:22 PM by fishmanlee
doubleofive's avatar
RE: The OT.com J. R. R. Tolkien & Middle Earth Discussion Thread

fishmanlee said:


The reason the EE is so short, is because the Theatrical is so long.
And because the book is so short. Did we really think he could pump 3 3.5 hour movies out of The Hobbit?

Star Wars Revisited Wordpress / Google+ / Facebook / Twitter

Cinetropolis - My new movie blog home

Where to hear me online

fishmanlee's avatar
RE: The OT.com J. R. R. Tolkien & Middle Earth Discussion Thread

doubleofive said:

 

fishmanlee said:


The reason the EE is so short, is because the Theatrical is so long.
And because the book is so short. Did we really think he could pump 3 3.5 hour movies out of The Hobbit?

 

And the Appendices, and Unfinished Tales, The History of Middle-Earth series..

timdiggerm's avatar
RE: The OT.com J. R. R. Tolkien & Middle Earth Discussion Thread

fishmanlee said:

doubleofive said:

 

fishmanlee said:


The reason the EE is so short, is because the Theatrical is so long.
And because the book is so short. Did we really think he could pump 3 3.5 hour movies out of The Hobbit?

 

And the Appendices, and Unfinished Tales, The History of Middle-Earth series..

Just the appendices. They have the rights to anything in the books LOTR & Hobbit, but nothing from the other books.

fishmanlee's avatar
RE: The OT.com J. R. R. Tolkien & Middle Earth Discussion Thread

I don't think Ungoliant was mentioned in the Appendices...?

timdiggerm's avatar
RE: The OT.com J. R. R. Tolkien & Middle Earth Discussion Thread

fishmanlee said:

I don't think Ungoliant was mentioned in the Appendices...?

This is why some of the references surprise me.

Mithrandir's avatar
RE: The OT.com J. R. R. Tolkien & Middle Earth Discussion Thread

fishmanlee said:

Erebor in glory vs. Moria in Decline....

 

Yes, that could be a point about how well the stances look, but i don't think the scale and amount of rooms could be justified by it. Even goblin town looks bigger than Moria from FOTR.

That said, the most outstanding case would be Dale looking as big as Minas Tirith. Speaking of which, the architecture and materials used in Dale look more mediterranean, and more southern than those from the south of middle earth.

Members reading this topic: None