Great!

I was wondering tho if you will enhance the door that dooku comes out.

Stylisticaly speaking we have to hear a sound before palps says "count dooku"

Also instead of a sudden close (because all the doors in the ship are slow as hell) you can make a more interesting effect. to brake that 2d layer look.

And add some lights behind the door to indicate that there some hall or an elevator aka vader in death star II.

A question: When obi cuts the super droids is something wrong with the cut there? i mean in your version i see the screen trembling/waving like trying to fade a rough cut or something..

-Angel

It was a bad spot in the sorce video, I need to pan the replacement footage to match up better The door, video wise I'll see what I can do. At the moment I wanna get the editing done. So I can Rar it and get some reviewers to look it all over story wise, then I'll focus on the details. Let me know If you wanna be a tester. Right now I could use at least 2 more people. I'm typing this on my Blackberry, sorry if it looks odd

Just if you missed that i ve spot some shit here and there that you might want to fix/eliminate from your edit:

Quote myself

Some shots for your consideration :)

Anakin and obi wan. Its a reshoot. The lightning, the scar, clothing and hair are changing between shots.

Also flipped zoomed reused shot

I fix this long time ago. In fact i dont remember who asked me to use my mockup to his edit .

One shot Anakin is on the shot. In the other he isnt.

Sorry for the page stretch :)

-Angel

Hey guys. I've been kinda MIA lately... Been on vacation and learned that my wife is pregnant. So, yeah, I've been a bit distracted.

I've still been following the thread over at FE, but had no clue it was here.

Anyway, guys, this could be my preferred Ep. 3 edit. It's looking amazing, and I can't wait to give it a look.

I know personally that Bob has gone above and beyond to deliver this one.

mrbenja0618 said:

I know personally that Bob has gone above and beyond to deliver this one.

I second that :D

-Angel

The last one was a easy fix vaderios, think it still looks ok.

I read the one about Vader missing the neck piece. not sure how I'll deal with that yet. Maybe I'll work on it in the final touchups.

The scene with Anakin and Obi, I cut that scene up pretty well, so not sure what footage is still in there, but I take a look at it.

Thanks for the tips 8)

Release date? lol 

I kid. Take your time.

bobgarcia74 said:

I'll upload it and send you the links for a test viewing Benj. 8)

I want one too! :'(

-Angel

I asked in a post earlier if you wanted to be a reviewer, hehe.

I'll send you the links too once there up. The one I just rendered today has a few flickers, so I'm fixing then right now as I watch it. Then I'll re-render it and upload it asap. Might be a bit tho.

It must slipped by my optic sensors :(

Well yeah id happy to :D

What you will use as provider? rapidshare (i got premium on that :D)

-Angel

I use Megaupload. You should be able to grab the links tho, np.

Rendering it right now. That last version was a flickerfest. So I cleaned it all up. Soon as it available you'll know.

Mostly want a review story wise. I know all the effects are not complete. Lightsabers are changed but not completely perfect.  A few audio transitions are off also. But feel free to comment on as much as you like. Cause maybe there's something you'll mention that I didn't intend to deal with.

I want to get the cuts settled first . So I can dive back into the effects and audio that I'll need to replace. Would hate to spend hours fixing stuff that I would maybe take out in the end version. If you know what I mean.

mrbenja0618 said:

...learned that my wife is pregnant.

Release date? lol 

I kid. Take your time.

;-)

lol

bobgarcia74 said:

I use Megaupload. You should be able to grab the links tho, np.

Awesome!

Mostly want a review story wise. I know all the effects are not complete. Lightsabers are changed but not completely perfect.  A few audio transitions are off also. But feel free to comment on as much as you like. Cause maybe there's something you'll mention that I didn't intend to deal with.

I will give a full feedback with what i saw/experienced ;)

Keep it up bob ;)

-Angel

TV's Frink said:

mrbenja0618 said:

...learned that my wife is pregnant.

 

Release date? lol 

I kid. Take your time.

;-)

 

Haha. Well if my math is right, and I'm correct when the conception occurred... I'm thinking late November/early December. My brother in law often jokes that the baby will come out a Wookie. =) Would be tragic at first, but then we would be rich.... But then again, my wife would have some explaining to do.

Benj and vaderios. Raring the avi right now. Took forever to render. I'll be uploading them soon, then I'll PM the links. 8) Hope its flicker free, cause I havnt had a chance to preview it yet.

Thanks for the links :)

A long feedback being sent :)

-Angel

Thanks for taking the time to look it over. Reading your thoughts now. Then tomorrow its back to editing 8)

Great :D

Take your time :)

-Angel

bobgarcia74, I've been looking for a good ROTS edit for ESB:Ren. Could I preview your edit as well?

Sorry Bob. Still downloading. I should have it done today... Curse of the non premium account member. I'm gonna try and have some feedback for you this weekend.