cain spaans said:

yes but ideas are good

the edit button is good

taking a few moments before hitting the post button is good

Neglify said:

This is excellent news. It's been too long since the last behind-the-scenes compilation of Episode IV. Can't wait to watch yours and then meticulously delete every memory of any previous STAR WARS docs. And then in 5 years I can make my own documentary edit that destroys your trash.

we'll see about that

Neglify said:

This is excellent news. It's been too long since the last behind-the-scenes compilation of Episode IV. Can't wait to watch yours and then meticulously delete every memory of any previous STAR WARS docs. And then in 5 years I can make my own documentary edit that destroys your trash.

please start a thread so I can follow progress

Who needs pat man 2 when you have this?!

STAR WARS: behind the ear

This is the best new thread on this site for sooo many reasons. I'm enjoying every minute since the opening salvo in post 1.

Surely what is being suggested here isn't a fan-edit of any of the Star Wars films, television shows or the like so it should be in perversasions and other projects??

The thing I find interesting is that you claim that this will be the greatest documentary on SW ever, yet you don't have editing software and you've never done a fanedit, so all we have is you flapping your lips. Can you give us some samples of your work to back up your claims?

thunderclap said:

The thing I find interesting is that you claim that this will be the greatest documentary on SW ever, yet you don't have editing software and you've never done a fanedit, so all we have is you flapping your lips. Can you give us some samples of your work to back up your claims?

well if no one like this and where it is going I will just call it quits 

Is it finished yet?

It certainly could be a great documentary.  But you provide little insight into your plans, show little promise because you are asking for pirated editing software, and your wording is insulting to very high quality existing documentaries.  I doubt you could match them simply because you have more resources.  But that doesn't mean it can't be done.  Just if you plan on doing it, try not to boast about your abilities that you've yet to demonstrate while simultaneously putting down others' excellent work.

What does behind the eye even mean, Macula (or is that Mooku)?

What does it mean!?  That doesn't matter!  What matters is if it sounds cool!

What I'm really hoping for is a Star War Holiday Special at 4k projected in some Texas town.  I'd be willing to sell all my Star Wars stuff for $ to see that one!

Well I don't think I will continue after all of your negative comments so yeah and the Star Wars holiday special sucks by the way

cain spaans said:

Well I don't think I will continue after all of your negative comments so yeah and the Star Wars holiday special sucks by the way

Unfortunately, you invited those negative comments by failing to conform to the norms of this community.

To understand what I mean, read post #62 of this thread very carefully.

FWIW, I made a similar mistake in Off Topic once and I learned my lesson. My advice to you (if you plan to stick around, that is) is to man-up and move on.

AntcuFaalb said:

To understand what I mean, read post #62 of this thread very carefully.

 

I submit that post #2 is the most important one in this thread.

As is the norm.

This is all true but I guess I will still try to look for the alternate narration for the making of Star Wars 

As is said above, take your lumps and bumps and move on, don't let anyone stop you. If it's something you still believe in, go right ahead with your project. But in future if you want your project received with more warmth... instead of making your first post like this:

cain spaans said:

STAR WARS: behind the eye is a new fan documentary that I want to make that will end all the other fan documentary's such as deleted magic building empire and returning to jedi this is one out of three documentary's containing footage from official documentary's deleted scenes and other material

...I'd suggest something more like this...

cain spaans (Could have) said:

'STAR WARS: BEHIND THE EYE' is a new fan documentary that I want to make.

The fantastic work by editors such as Jamie Benning on projects like 'Building empire' and 'Returning To Jedi' has inspired me to do something similar. This edit will be incorporating some of the latest footage not available when those projects were compiled and where possible will be in glorious HD!

This will be the first FanEdit I've attempted so I'd appreciate everyone's advice on what is the best software to use. Also if you can suggest footage and ideas that would be fantastic!

More deatils to follow Star Wars fans!

Sounds better right? Some basic formatting would've hepled for a start, rather than a spew of lowercase words. Either that or hire a PR management team ;-)

Ryan McAvoy said:

As is said above, take your lumps and bumps and move on, don't let anyone stop you. If it's something you still believe in, go right ahead with your project. But in future if you want your project received with more warmth... instead of making your first post like this:

cain spaans said:

STAR WARS: behind the eye is a new fan documentary that I want to make that will end all the other fan documentary's such as deleted magic building empire and returning to jedi this is one out of three documentary's containing footage from official documentary's deleted scenes and other material

...I'd suggest something more like this...

cain spaans (Could have) said:

'STAR WARS: BEHIND THE EYE' is a new fan documentary that I want to make.

The fantastic work by editors such as Jamie Benning on projects like 'Building empire' and 'Returning To Jedi' has inspired me to do something similar. This edit will be incorporating some of the latest footage not available when those projects were compiled and where possible will be in glorious HD!

This will be the first FanEdit I've attempted so I'd appreciate everyone's advice on what is the best software to use. Also if you can suggest footage and ideas that would be fantastic!

More deatils *RECORD SCRATCH*

:P

Ryan McAvoy said:

As is said above, take your lumps and bumps and move on, don't let anyone stop you. If it's something you still believe in, go right ahead with your project. But in future if you want your project received with more warmth... instead of making your first post like this:

cain spaans said:

STAR WARS: behind the eye is a new fan documentary that I want to make that will end all the other fan documentary's such as deleted magic building empire and returning to jedi this is one out of three documentary's containing footage from official documentary's deleted scenes and other material

...I'd suggest something more like this...

cain spaans (Could have) said:

'STAR WARS: BEHIND THE EYE' is a new fan documentary that I want to make.

The fantastic work by editors such as Jamie Benning on projects like 'Building empire' and 'Returning To Jedi' has inspired me to do something similar. This edit will be incorporating some of the latest footage not available when those projects were compiled and where possible will be in glorious HD!

This will be the first FanEdit I've attempted so I'd appreciate everyone's advice on what is the best software to use. Also if you can suggest footage and ideas that would be fantastic!

More deatils to follow Star Wars fans!

Sounds better right? Some basic formatting would've hepled for a start, rather than a spew of lowercase words. Either that or hire a PR management team ;-)

I agree with what you say thanks

I will be going to best buy and future shop to get a good editing software program