CP3S said:

 

 

TheBoost said:

I'd say it's not just a matter of prettiness, it's a matter of film presence too.

WRONG!!! I mean, seriously, who wants to look at closeups of Sarah Brightman for two hours?

;)

If you look at close ups of her for two minutes you wont have a choice. That woman's eyes can hypnotize you through the screen.

But when we are talking about a Musical,  doesn't the little matter of how well you can sing come into play?    In that department, Brightman beats  Rossum by a mile. 

CP3S said:

Warbler said:

I disagree with you.   You see the stage recording of Sweeney Todd, starring George Hern and Angela Lansbury...

Oh, I have seen it and I love it. It is probably one of the better recordings of a play I have seen.

It really saddens me that from now on Sweeney Todd will forever be remembered as a Tim Burton film starring Depp.

the movie isn't terrible, but again I wish it had been done years before, starring George Hern and Angela Lansbury.    I wish it had been directed by someone other than Tim Burton.  He's a weirdo.

its not for everyone I guess.

Warbler said:

the movie isn't terrible, but again I wish it had been done years before, starring George Hern and Angela Lansbury.    I wish it had been directed by someone other than Tim Burton.  He's a weirdo.

Brightman out sings Rossum by far more than a mile. There is really no comparison.

The look of Burton's Sweeney Todd is all wrong. It is too outlandish, too Burtonesque.

Hey, if I got out anymore I'd be feral, baby!

Burton fan, I take it?

Wait a minute! Bingo is making amateur porn videos with TV's Mom as well? I feel betrayed...

Wait, Bingo and your mom get paid for their movies?

:(

Maybe...

:(

*sigh*    could we cut out the porn talk?   

*sigh*