An $150 card that can only capture unencrypted HDMI or analog YPbPr to 13Mbps H.264 with no option for uncompressed 2-channel audio (forced AAC)
vs.
A $110 card that can capture any HDMI or YPbPr to uncompressed/lossless with uncompressed 2-channel audio
Not drinking that Hauppauge Kool-Aid.