TK-949 said:

 

CatBus said:

roback214 said:

Here's a sampler of the intro to Star Wars (Harmy 2.1) with scroll text in Spanish, as seen in Latin America in 1977. still work to do ... but it's a start. I think I can finally have STAR WARS as I saw as a child thanks to Harmy ... May the force be with you with version 2.5!!


http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nt8-_lCfa2o

I hope you're still planning to release those dubs!

Only, if you release something he needs.

 

Whoops, I just realized it's that prick again. Don't know, why I tried to help him out... must've been a reflex.

Yeah.

I am the of the stills ..

And I think it was a misunderstanding, I I have hundreds of photographs of the ILM (not from WEB) and private archives of known people who worked on STAR WARS, the forum member I offered him the pictures and just wanted to show me one small example of what I had, and I want to continue to increase my collection. Apparently he upset about this.
Another forum member very friendly and showed me some of his photographs and even perhaps have all their goodwill gesture coarse to send me photos in high resolution. (And today and tomorrow I will send many ...).
And also gave him another good material to other forum members ... I have a lot of material to share, but first you have to talk and befriend ....
My intention is not to make this a controversy, just give an alternative explanation of the facts ...

PS: Just read your post Catbus Thanks for your words ..... I send the link of the promised ....

roback214 said:

I have a lot of material to share, but first you have to talk and befriend

This, I think, is where there's a difference in culture. Why is sharing contingent on friendship?

And that's why I have a problem with him. Joining a collaborative community like ours comes with some adaption in behaviour. To me the OT.com community has always been about sharing and helping each other out. If I have something that can make someone else's project better, I'm happy to help out. And as far as I can tell that's pretty much how this whole community works. Need a missing audio track off a release that's not seeded anymore? Someone uploads it! Need something scanned? Done! My impression was, that this is something that's natural for projects like this.

Why do you need to increase your collection before you can help someone out? I don't really see the connection here...

Feallan said:

Let's ostracize him.

Let's not.

Harmy, I've begun asking around with some people I talk to at another site that do a lot of Blu-ray reauthoring (to add extra subtitles and/or audio tracks, etc.), to see what they have to say about the process.  I haven't heard much about what this one guy in particular uses (though I think it is mostly Scenarist), but his main bit of advise/caution was that you should be mindful of not going past the max bitrate, which includes all video, audio and subtitle stream bitrates at any given time.  So, the amount of audio tracks you want shouldn't be a problem, as long as there isn't too much data (even if just a spike) to stay within BD specs.  What I take from that is maybe we can't have more than just a few lossless tracks, or we could start running into bitrate issues...  I'll let you know if I hear more.  Also, do you have any questions you'd like me to pass along?

With the audio tracks at 16 bit (which compresses more efficiently than 24), and the video at 720p rather than 1080, that may not be an issue, but it's always good to keep in mind.  In any event the main soundtracks are the most important for lossless audio, and high bitrate lossy would suffice for the rest if there are any problems.

I have obtained the GOUT-synched '85 mix and created a new file matching its level to the other tracks, so there's now a complete set.  I want to start uploading them all tomorrow if I can.  I guess I'll use DTS-HD MA since Harmy doesn't know what he'll be creating the Bluray with, and it seems to be easier to author with this format.  Hopefully my connection is up to the task . . .