I've had no problems playing the AVCHD's in a PS3.  You might need an update. 

Harmy, your versions of SW and ESB are now my go-to versions as well.  I eagerly anticipate your ROTJ.

jwinters said:

first of all I want to say that I may just cancel my pre-order of the bluray set from amazon after seeing what an incredible job was done with empire.  simply incredible...

It's on!!! ;-D

 

That being said I am desperately seeking part three of the star wars post.  I wnt to tehparadox.com and attempted to download, all but 1 file was completed. 

I need this file:

sw-deed-hd-harmy-part3-rar

Can someone please help me?

PM sent.

Lastly, is return available yet or is it still in progress.

Not yet, I'm still working on it. There is also SW v1.2 on the horizon with a few errors fixed.

These editions are beyond awesome Harmy! I am really looking forward to checking them out :) I went through the comparisons for the first 2 movies today and I'm truly impressed by the work that has been put into it all!

Hope everything turns out well with ROTJ for you now! Btw, forgive me if this has been explained already(lots of posts to scan through), but is there a v.1.2 coming for ESB as well or is that one final? I rather prefer waiting until you're happy with everything before going on to obtain any of the releases :)

There's no plan for making another version of Empire, only SW :-)

Harmy, have you ever considered putting the "close the blast doors!" line into the audio track?  I know it's a personal choice, since there are official versions with and without.  The mono version seems the most thorough, and it has it.

Well, no, I'm totally useless with audio. But the mono mix is there.

But I think it would be a nice idea (as someone here already suggested) if one of the sound guys made a nice 5.1 mix that would have all the mono mix sound choices. But I'm definitely not the right guy to attempt something like that.

Harmy said:

But I think it would be a nice idea (as someone here already suggested) if one of the sound guys made a nice 5.1 mix that would have all the mono mix sound choices. But I'm definitely not the right guy to attempt something like that.

Yes, that would make a great project.  Oooh, a big project for sure.  Hmmm, maybe after finishing the rest of the OT I can try my hand at a "Puggo Mix".  It could be my excuse to get into 5.1 mixing, which I've been putting off in all my old-school stereo snobbery (rhymes with slobbery).

Harmy said:

But I think it would be a nice idea (as someone here already suggested) if one of the sound guys made a nice 5.1 mix that would have all the mono mix sound choices.

What all is in the mono mix that is missing from the 5.1?

Harmy said:

Well, no, I'm totally useless with audio. But the mono mix is there.

But I think it would be a nice idea (as someone here already suggested) if one of the sound guys made a nice 5.1 mix that would have all the mono mix sound choices. But I'm definitely not the right guy to attempt something like that.

Harmy, my ANH:Revisited 5.1 track has most of the mono mix dialogue, so that might be useful for you. I don;t think any sound effects were added in the places these lines were replaced

@DJ: There's quite a few differences, I couldn't list them all but I bet there's a list somewhere. Moth3r?

@Ady: Well, like I said, I'm definitely not gonna do that myself, I just think it would be a nice idea.

Here you can check out the most obvious differences in the mono mix: http://homepage.ntlworld.com/russdawson/mono/index.htm

There is however much more than what is on that list.

Thanks :-)

Well, I'm encoding the Jedi workprint now, which means, I'll start working on SW v1.2 soon, so if anyone has any more suggestions, speak now or forever hold your peace, because I'm NOT doing v1.3!!!

here's one that i would like to see but it's not a big deal.

in the end ceremony it looked like to me that the faces of luke and han when they come into the temple and walk up the isle are hard to focus on probably due to the HD source you used.  It could be due to a little dvnr smearing i'm not sure.  Are there other HD sources where their faces aren't as blurred?

But it's not that big of a thing.

Weird, I checked it and I'm not seeing this at all.

http://i51.tinypic.com/2eb5zme.jpg
http://i51.tinypic.com/29ofhuw.jpg
http://i54.tinypic.com/xcsjcw.jpg
http://i55.tinypic.com/f028zr.jpg
http://i55.tinypic.com/24n3b10.jpg
http://i54.tinypic.com/2hd1p50.png
http://i52.tinypic.com/f56rfa.png

lukes and hans heads keep going in and out of focus.

it's most noticable on lukes eyes in that shot

it may not be fixable.

joshdv said:

http://i51.tinypic.com/2eb5zme.jpg
http://i51.tinypic.com/29ofhuw.jpg
http://i54.tinypic.com/xcsjcw.jpg
http://i55.tinypic.com/f028zr.jpg
http://i55.tinypic.com/24n3b10.jpg
http://i54.tinypic.com/2hd1p50.png
http://i52.tinypic.com/f56rfa.png

 

lukes and hans heads keep going in and out of focus.

it's most noticable on lukes eyes in that shot

it may not be fixable.

It's motion blur, not an error.

Thank, Ady, that's what I thought, I just wasn't sure whether I wasn't missing anything.

Yep, that's there, someone already pointed this out to me (might have been in a PM). Seems like for some reason there's a missing frame. I'll see what I can do about it, hopefully this problem doesn't appear in other sources.

For me just the shots of Luke training aboard the Falcon with those laser bolts and that  Jedi firing a white laser shot that is suppose to be yellow.

-That bit of sky around the Dewback next to the cantina.

  I thought I would throw this out there.  Is there anything that can be done with those sanddunes. When 3PO says "I am not going that way."

It does look a little different. I don't think that sand moving on the left was originally there.

 -I don't know if anything can be done about that little bit of motion blur when the escape pod is jettison from the Blockade Runner.

 The bit of circle of light on the floor when the stromtrooper are knoocking on doors.

 Luke says "Its too dangerous with the sandpeople we will have til wait." That shot looks good. Thats one you said you may redo with a different technique.

I am very happy with V.1.   Thanks you so, so much for being kind  and responding to pm.  Like one member said "At this point you are just polishing gold."

  Troy