pittrek
This user is offline.
Padawan LearnerTroyig88 said:
I think pittrek was joking when he wrote that. That was a outstanding featurette.
Of course, I hoped it was clear :-) I'm a big fan of Harmy's work
Gomu69
This user is offline.
Impressive nonetheless to seamlessly tribute all of the collective efforts that went into this cohesively in a manner which takes complicated work and blends it all in a nicely wrapped package of goodness full of gratitude and dedication.
BuzziRules
This user is offline.
^ Exactly.
teoalcantara
This user is offline.
W-O-W!!!!
I do LIKE your voice AND I absolutely LOVED the "featurette".
Your diction is clear, I had no trouble at all understanding you, and I'm brazilian!
The only room for improvement IMHO would be the "DESPECIALIZED" title treatment. It is a bit too simple/crude when compared to the overall utterly professional work you've done.
IMHO, the "Despecialized Edition" logo that appears on 10m55s is a lot better, for example.
Also, I hope it's not too late to mention, but I've noticed a "shake" in the position of the red turbine of the x-wing fighter on the left side, at 8m19s aprox.
Puggo - Jar Jar's Yoda
This user is offline.
legendary but little-known Jedi MasterHOLY FRIGGIN' CRAP!!! That was awesome!!! And to think you didn't want to do a "making of" documentary???
Would YouTube reject this thing? 'Cause the world should see it.
analog
This user is offline.
Cannot wait to see the clip :)
Really loved the comparison galleries, so I think this will be nice to see in video form! Thanks for putting that together, and for letting us have a "sneak preview" of it!
analog
This user is offline.
Good question - probably so. It's probably on their threshold of "too grey" an area, and it'd probably be taken down pretty quickly.
The Griff
This user is offline.
Very cool video. Now I can show this to friends rather than talk over the movie about how great it all is.
Harmy
This user is offline.
Han D. SoloYeah, unfortunately, from experience, this would probably get blocked on YouTube within minutes.
teoalcantara said:
W-O-W!!!!
I do LIKE your voice AND I absolutely LOVED the "featurette".
Your diction is clear, I had no trouble at all understanding you, and I'm brazilian!
Yeah, I was recording that with foreign audience in mind :-)
The only room for improvement IMHO would be the "DESPECIALIZED" title treatment. It is a bit too simple/crude when compared to the overall utterly professional work you've done.
IMHO, the "Despecialized Edition" logo that appears on 10m55s is a lot better, for example.
I like the logo this way - pure and simple.
Also, I hope it's not too late to mention, but I've noticed a "shake" in the position of the red turbine of the x-wing fighter on the left side, at 8m19s aprox.
It's supposed to do that - it did in the original :-)
Pennsylvania Jones said:
"Stick and Stones will break my bones but the Blu-Rays will never Harmy."
Lucas: I am altering the film. Pray I don't alter it any further.
Fans: This film is getting worse all the time!
Troyig88
This user is offline.
Padawan LearnerI second what Puggo said.
looking for HDTV of the Attack of the Clones and Revenge of the Sith. Also HDTV of The Lord of the Rings trilogy
DragoonClawNZ
This user is offline.
I don't like sand, it's so....sandy.I just watched the featurette last night and I loved it. Didn't mind your voice at all too. :) Looking forward to seeing the rest when v2.5 is released.
"There is no peace, peace is a lie" -Start of the Sith Code
analog
This user is offline.
Very well done clip!!! Very, very cool to see some of the wipes showing several sources. I can't wait to show this to a friend who's recently been introduced to the "Despecialized" world :)
This is very professional, Harmy. The pacing on your commentary is also very well done, and nicely spaced out. Really enjoyed seeing this. Thank you!
Kingherb
This user is offline.
I get this message when trying to download the documentary '' Availability of this file has timed out. If you wish to download this file, please, contact the uploader. ''
Harmy
This user is offline.
Han D. SoloIt should hopefully work now :-)
Thank for all the nice comments guys :-)
Also, check out the little clip in the ESB thread.
Pennsylvania Jones said:
"Stick and Stones will break my bones but the Blu-Rays will never Harmy."
Lucas: I am altering the film. Pray I don't alter it any further.
Fans: This film is getting worse all the time!
Kingherb
This user is offline.
Harmy said:
It should hopefully work now :-)
Thank for all the nice comments guys :-)
Also, check out the little clip in the ESB thread.
Thanks it is downloading now, looking forward to it :)
b0bafett
This user is offline.
I just watched your making of documentary, Harmy and I've got to say well done! I didn't realize just how many different sources you've used.
Amazing stuff!
timdiggerm
This user is offline.
That was fantastic. So good to see it all put in one feature like that!
HanDuet
This user is offline.
Greetings, fellow Star Wars fans!
Although I have been following this project and this forum thread for quite some time, I believe this is the first time for me to make a post. Thus, I can't move on until I extend my deep gratitude to Harmy and everyone else involved in the various fan preservation projects of Star Wars for all your hard work, incredible attention to detail, and selfless hours of dedication. I am immeasurably grateful to be one of the many fans who will share in the benefits of this project to reconstruct the original masterpiece of the Star Wars trilogy.
I have broken my silence as a forum lurker to announce that I have uploaded Harmy's Video Sources Documentary for Star Wars: Despecialized Edition to YouTube. Harmy, I realize you have had trouble with YouTube in the past and some of your uploaded videos were removed as a result of copyright claims. However, I agree with Puggo: The world should see this video - it does an incredible job introducing and explaining the purpose and methods of your Despecialized Edition edit of Star Wars.
We'll see if YouTube removes this video, too. If they do, I'll be the one taking the fall for it, and that's a risk I'm happy to take for this project. For now, the video is live at the following link:
EDIT: The video has been re-uploaded at higher quality (as discussed in the following replies on this thread. The new link is:
Thanks again, and keep up the good work! I'm looking forward to the upcoming release of SW DE v2.5 and the future 2.0 version of ESB & ROTJ!
Harmy
This user is offline.
Han D. SoloThanks for uploading :-)
Pennsylvania Jones said:
"Stick and Stones will break my bones but the Blu-Rays will never Harmy."
Lucas: I am altering the film. Pray I don't alter it any further.
Fans: This film is getting worse all the time!
Kingherb
This user is offline.
Great work Harmy, i have watched this 3 times now.
Flexicon9
This user is offline.
michaeldc
This user is offline.
Hi Harmy, I signed up basically to let you know how awesome you are and how impressed I am by all this - I just watched the documentary on the sources and I'm simply blown away, it's absolutely incredible. You should be extremely proud.
I downloaded the latest version of the three films and they are stunning. I can't wait to have the BD discs for all three (however long that will take!) and it'll be the version I show my nephews and kids one day in the future for sure.
This is simply as good as I was hoping Lucasfilm would give us (and probably better). It's incredible and as LF has no intention of restoring the originals it's so reassuring to know that you done this - it is, what I have wanted for years now.
A million thanks to you.
Jetrell Fo
This user is online.
Padawan LearnerOkay, I just watched the documentary ...... very, very cool. Nicely done.
ray_afraid
This user is offline.
Twisted & EvilVery nice documentary. I love those wipes from Bluray to Despecialized! I would love to see an entire featurette of just that!
Moth3r
This user is offline.
Better Grumpy than DopeyExcellent feature Harmy, really good to highlight all the problems with the official releases.
Would be nice to see Hairy Hen do something about the restoration of the 70mm mix.
Also, does everyone pronounce AVISynth as "avvysynth" or is it just you? ;-)