Well I still thank your for spending 8 months on this,now lets make these preservation Know.   

@ Harmy:

640Kbps is within AVCHD spec. :

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AVCHD

http://www.avchd-info.org/format/

pat man said:

lets make these preservation Know.   

I usually just like giving people hell for poor English, but in this case I really can't figure out the meaning.

Like make the Originals known form the preservations

pat man said:

Let's make the Originals known to all the fans out there with these preservations.

^^ Fixed.  Ease up, Frink.  English isn't his first language, but his heart's in the right place.  :)

Nearsighted Scrappile said:

 Ease up, Frink.

That's a contradiction.

U.S. English is make only language(not a good speller),But yea thats what I mean.

I don't like to be Off-topic 

Nearsighted Scrappile said:

English isn't his first language

I made that mistake a while back myself.

And lol, Puggo.

I've made a torrent for the fixed DVD5 over at the spleen if anybody's looking for it; CatBus nuked his upload of the old one some time earlier today.

crissrudd4554 said:

Also the shot of the fleet taking off (with the white flashes) in the original it was four ships in each row but in your cut it looks like 3 ships in each row. Was that intentional or was that an accident?

Your comment made me discover yet another change that's gone unnoticed: http://originaltrilogy.com/forum/topic.cfm/Complete-Comparison-of-Special-Edition-Visual-Changes/post/594949/#TopicPost594949

That's simple why I didn't use the GOUT. Because it looks like crap. And as to that ships taking off shot, I never noticed that, so it's indeed probably a little mistake. The fourth ships are still there but much less visible.

Harmy said:

Here is a frame from the Jedi1.net scans and MV's screen photo recoloured to the colours of my reference source automatically using the colorlike avisynth plugin:

just watched your version on a bigscreen tv yesterday,

it matched our's pretty closely also... for some reason

watching it on a tv with different settings was quite

different from viewing it on a monitor....

i'm used to watching almost all my videos on monitors,

so it's just a matter of setting your color preferences

to match what you think is right.

later

-1

bilditup1 said:

I've made a torrent for the fixed DVD5 over at the spleen if anybody's looking for it; CatBus nuked his upload of the old one some time earlier today.

 Thanks!

CatBus said:

bilditup1 said:

I've made a torrent for the fixed DVD5 over at the spleen if anybody's looking for it; CatBus nuked his upload of the old one some time earlier today.

 Thanks!

Yeah dude no problem!

Harmy said:

That's simple why I didn't use the GOUT. Because it looks like crap. 

Looking forward to the day when the GOUT is a thing of the past! (And yeah, the quality difference for just a few frames...obviously not worth it.) 

Rox64 said:

Sorry if this has been asked before, but will the Bluray have a bigger bitrate and quality than the MKV released?

Harmy has said that he's going to use the same bitrate for the video. There may be lossless audio from h_h, don't quite remember.

Yeah. There would really be nothing to be gained from using a higher bitrate. And, ok, I'm just gonna go out and say it, even though it's against my better judgement - I will likely do a new render for the BD in which I will fix a few things. I would still prefer any problem be reported via PM, so that I'm not caved in by an avalanche of suggestions and people trying to convince me to fix stuff I don't want to fix.

I might lower the gamma slightly on a few shots in the Luke meets Ben scene, but that's as far as I'm going with it.

All I can say is : THANKS

What's the latest on the AVCHD being uploaded?

Muxing it now, so if everything goes well it could be online in an hour or two.