FrederikOlsen
This user is offline.
negative1 has mentioned on more than one occassion that any screengrabs that are posted here might be temporary in terms of colour timing or suffer from compression. Don't worry - I'd say he definitely knows what he's doing.
Besides, as has been mentioned several times here (and other places), the GOUT DVDs can't really be used as accurate references for colour timing. Sure, the crushed blacks (and other issues) of the '04 DVDs and the Blu-rays are over the top, but it's important to note that "Star Wars" wasn't always pretty or consistent. Check out this article for more info on that.
djchaseb
This user is offline.
I watched both workprints again last night it really does look amazing. I feel like a kid before Christmas waiting for the final :)
Hostmaster
This user is offline.
Bounty HunterDoomBot said:
Darn, wish i could get into spleen.
Much better in "teh paradox"! ;-)
He's no good to me dead
Harmy
This user is offline.
Han D. SoloNot really. Not at all actually, the are no links there anymore.
Pennsylvania Jones said:
"Stick and Stones will break my bones but the Blu-Rays will never Harmy."
Lucas: I am altering the film. Pray I don't alter it any further.
Fans: This film is getting worse all the time!
DoomBot
This user is offline.
Yeah at this point torrents are a better deal. These file lockers for free users are becoming worse.
Harmy
This user is offline.
Han D. SoloOK, here's the WP of reel 3. There will still be a few minor changes but for the most part this should be final:
Pennsylvania Jones said:
"Stick and Stones will break my bones but the Blu-Rays will never Harmy."
Lucas: I am altering the film. Pray I don't alter it any further.
Fans: This film is getting worse all the time!
Harmy
This user is offline.
Han D. SoloOK, guys. As some of you know I'm a university student and my major is English. Now, in order to finish my studies, I have to write a 30 - 40 page thesis. I should have been working on this for ages but being the stupid lazy slob that I am, I kept neglecting it, as well as my other school stuff and procrastinated by working on my edits. Actually, I was hoping to have the edit done by now, so I could take a break from editing and work on it but it didn't exactly work out. Now I'm going to need your help to get this done as quickly as possible, because the deadline is getting dangerously close, which I didn't realize (I thought the deadline was a month later than it actually is) so I'm gonna have to stop working on the edit (or at least slow down quite a bit) until I'm done with the thesis.
Why I think you can help is because I was lucky enough to be able to choose STAR WARS as my topic (under the subject of "American Cutural Studies.") My topic is something along the lines of "STAR WARS, American Cultural Heritage."
I'd like to analyse what it it is that makes STAR WARS such a great cultural phenomenon and underline its importance as an American cultural landmark.
It's a little absurd that they want us to show critical thinking in the work but at the same time we have to back every single idea with a citation, so I need sources, lots of them. I turn to you because I know this place is an incredible well of knowledge on this subject and there are people here who can point me to the exact right places. I need quotations from documentaries, film historians, academic books etc.
The thing is, I need the exact places, it's like I've read The Secret History of Star Wars (and it was awesome too) but if I was to find some quote in there, I'd be quite lost.
I started a thread here, so if you can help, please post there but keep any discussion about the edit here, I need that thread to stay on topic.
Thank you!
Help me, OT.com, you're my only hope!
Pennsylvania Jones said:
"Stick and Stones will break my bones but the Blu-Rays will never Harmy."
Lucas: I am altering the film. Pray I don't alter it any further.
Fans: This film is getting worse all the time!
Mavimao
This user is online.
Padawan LearnerI never felt tempted to download the other reels because I wanted to wait for the finished product, but I saw your last link and I couldn't help the temptation and went ahead and downloaded it.
Wow. It's one thing to see it in pictures and it's another to see it in motion. Like others have said, the color timing is retro-tastic. You really feel like you're watching a film from the 70s. Great job on that front.
I just skimmed through it, and it's late here so I am going to hit the hay, but I'll give more detailed criticisms if I can find any.
What's the internal temperature of a TaunTaun? Luke warm.
Harmy
This user is offline.
Han D. SoloGreat, thanks :-)
Pennsylvania Jones said:
"Stick and Stones will break my bones but the Blu-Rays will never Harmy."
Lucas: I am altering the film. Pray I don't alter it any further.
Fans: This film is getting worse all the time!
red5-626
This user is offline.
I No My Spelling and Grammar Stinks. If I offend I am Sorry.
I do not know where your going but in hi school I did a paper on the story of Star Wars and Joseph Campbell’s books helped a lot.
vbangle
This user is offline.
I am ready for the trials!You are really out doing yourself harmy, great job. Looks wonderful!
I love everybody. Lets all smoke some reefer and chill. Hug and kisses for everybody.
djchaseb
This user is offline.
The color and detail is just fantastic. I'm noticing things I've never noticed before and that amazes me! Absolutely can't wait to see the finished product.
CatBus
This user is offline.
A légpárnás hajóm tele van angolnákkal.I'm just loving the fact that I'm even able to notice grain on Star Wars. On Star Wars! Zero complaints with the newest workprint.
snicker
This user is offline.
Harmy, this is looking unbelievably good. I haven't been through the whole workprint but I noticed something that really stood out It's a shot that I know you've laboured over (and over) so I hate to point it out. In the first shot of the cantina Dewback starting at 00:41:50:17 there's a patch of what looks like blurred compression artifacts or large grain above the Dewback's head. Because it doesn't move it really stands out. The green grain in there also stands out unlike the green grain patch on the left which looks inherent. Could you render those few frames and patch heal that area in Photoshop? Alternatively you could mask it in Premiere and apply a bit of noise with a little blur. I gotta say, being able to watch the Mos Eisley sequence without the CGI additions is a wonderful thing and a shitload of work.
snicker
This user is offline.
Just want to add that the other Dewback shots are perfectly integrated. Had a quick skim through the rest of the workprint and couldn't see anything else that stood out as a fix. You've really nailed the colours too.
keysersoze5
This user is offline.
Hey Harmy, I'd like to point something out. During the scene where R2 and 3PO are hiding behind the door and the stormtroopers are inspecting the area, part of the background warps a little. I'm guessing that this was due to removing the flying probe droid or whatever the hell that thing is and using GOUT footage to try and mask part of it.
But aside from that and the establishing shot of the cantina that somebody already pointed out, everything seems to look great, and I haven't found any other problems yet. I was quite surprised by the green tint in the scene where Vader and Tarkin discuss how extract info from Leia, but if that's how it's supposed to look, that's how it's supposed to look.
Oh and one more thing, did you do something different to the shot where the Falcon takes off and the troopers watch it ascend?
"Oh, don't sell yourself short Judge, you're a tremendous slouch."
KeyserSoze
This user is offline.
Just watched reel 3... most impressive.
Harmy
This user is offline.
Han D. SoloYeah, I'm aware of all of the problems you guys pointed out, I'm gonna be able to fix some, but some will have to stay the way they are (the shaky background in the "door is locked" shot for example).
And yeah, I made the look and compositing of Falcon in the shot of it leaving Mos Eisley closer to the original.
Pennsylvania Jones said:
"Stick and Stones will break my bones but the Blu-Rays will never Harmy."
Lucas: I am altering the film. Pray I don't alter it any further.
Fans: This film is getting worse all the time!
petemct
This user is offline.
Stunning work Harmy, cannot wait to download and watch the whole thing!
negative1
This user is offline.
negative1pittrek said:
bspaunhorst said:
I'm sure that this shot was like this in the original, but it just looks really out of place.
The scenes before and after it, the sky is a nice blue, but this closeup it is very red. If it was supposed to be like that as per the original, that's fine by me, just is a bit off to me.
Yes, it IS correct - this scene always had red sky
here's our slightly brightened version:
-----

later
-1
[no GOUT in CED?-> GOUT CED]
teoalcantara
This user is offline.
Hi everyone,
Regarding the above screenshots, personally I think the despecialized one looks better than the slightly brightened up, because skin tones are more natural, Luke's robe is white and C3PO color also looks better (more golden than yellow).
Oh, I don't know if it's worth mentioning, but since this is the purpose of the workprint after all (to evaluate progress), I've noticed some things in the reel 3 (the only one I've downloaded so far):
1) Sound seems a little bit distorted, as if volume was a tad too high, but this can be due to mp4 compression or my codecs/player fault (I use MPC-HC);
2) I don't know if it has always been like that (and probably it WAS, due to Special FX technical limitations of the era the film was made), but at 00:56:18:23 and 00:56:58:18 (Luke's saber going off and on) it felt to me like there was a jump cut /missing frame;
3) I've noticed some compression artifacts near C3PO's arms (00:40:41:22) and head (00:40:54:10) - I think they're called 'mosquito noise'?
Hammy, I know it's been said 1000 times already, but your work is simply put FANTASTIC. Thank you!!!!
TV's Frink
This user is offline.
Ointment FlyBest typo ever.vbangle said:
You are really out doing yourself harmy, great job.
Harmy
This user is offline.
Han D. SoloLOL, didn't notice that. Though to be honest, I usually prefer to stay in when indulging in such activities ;-)
Pennsylvania Jones said:
"Stick and Stones will break my bones but the Blu-Rays will never Harmy."
Lucas: I am altering the film. Pray I don't alter it any further.
Fans: This film is getting worse all the time!
keysersoze5
This user is offline.
Harmy said:
Yeah, I'm aware of all of the problems you guys pointed out, I'm gonna be able to fix some, but some will have to stay the way they are (the shaky background in the "door is locked" shot for example).
Is there any way to reduce the shakiness like you did with the dewback shots?
"Oh, don't sell yourself short Judge, you're a tremendous slouch."
Jaitea
This user is offline.
Has anyone ever seen this image before?

J