Mazaliche
This user is offline.
Hello!
I love fullscreen versions of films ( open matte or pan & scanned ). I'm particularly fond of pan & scans of movies that REALLY shouldn't be pan & scanned ( think "The Deer Hunter", "The Fall of the Roman Empire", "The Magnificent 7", "The Great Escape", "Ben-Hur"... ). They're fascinating.
I own many of those on DVD, and love the restoration job and the fact that I can finally watch them in their original aspect ratio, which is my favorite way of watching them, but I'm really sad to see pan & scan go. They have not only nostalgic value, they are also historically interesting, in the sense that this was the way most people first encountered those movies for the best part of the last 40 years, and also because new releases usually have slightly different cuts / revamped special effects / color timing, and other tweaks. Just like deleted scenes or alternate takes on a DVD, these versions tell you a little more about the film.
So I was wondering if there are more people out there who feel the way I do. There were a few fullscreen DVDs early in the format ( either stand-alone releases or flippies ( Widescreen on one side, fullscreen on the other ), laserdisc for a few prominent titles, and vhs for the rest. I hear Netflix also makes some movies available in fullscreen.
I do not have the resources, technical knowledge or money to own, convert or download everything I'm interested in, I have never even touched a laserdisc player, but if I didn't think so strongly about piracy, I'd love it if like-minded people were to post a reply with their thoughts on this or maybe shoot me a pm about fullscreen laserdisc-to-dvd conversions and other such material...
By the way, I happen to be a member at a number of trackers, under the same username. Isn't that a funny coincidence?
MrBrown
This user is offline.
I really like open matte Full screen Versions.
i.e. I've seen From Dusk till Dawn and Desperado open matte on German VHS first, before seeing them widescreen.
I really would love to have the open matte Versions as DVDs, but afaik they were matted for LDs, and they were only Fullscreen on VHS.
My first DVD of Bad Taste was a bad full frame german release, which I gave away after getting a better quality Widescreen Version. Now I am trying to get that again. Same with Evil Dead. I am glad that at least the US company released Evil Dead as Full Frame Version.
I have a german languaged only DVD of an open Matted "Killing Zoe"
Too bad that open Matte Versions seem to die away, because I always loved the way some movies show some more informations, or some faulty of screen things like microphones...
"I kill Gandalf." - Igor, Dork Tower
Mazaliche
This user is offline.
Nice to have some feedback, Mr. Brown.
I just remembered another movie I'd just love to have the OPEN MATTE fullscreen version of: the 1956 "Invasion of the Body Snatchers".
As it came out during the years of transition to widescreen, it appears to have been shown theatrically in different aspect ratios. The original fullscreen version, however, ONLY HAS SURVIVED as a 16mm...
The best material available is of the matted widescreen version, and the fullscreen versions floating around are pan & scans of that widescreen version...
http://www.northwestchicagofilmsociety.org/2012/07/02/invasion-of-the-aspect-ratios/
Wouldn't you love to have a look at that 16mm print? Wouldn't it be great if Criterion released this movie? Not only because of this aspect ratio problem, but because the movie invites the kind of discussion that dvd supplements love to deal with, and also because a series of interviews with cast and crew and other related material has been produced through the years, but are scattered along a few of its home video incarnations or gathering dust in some vault. This movie deserves the royal treatment!