Joshua_Blue
This user is offline.
Here it the new conference room video: http://vimeo.com/31169717
I still does need some tweaking, but generally this is it.
DominicCobb
This user is offline.
Joshua_Blue said:
Here it the new conference room video: http://vimeo.com/31169717
I still does need some tweaking, but generally this is it.
At :38 there's a shot of Tarkin that lasts about a second. It's a bit jarring. You should either make it longer, or take it out all together.
Joshua_Blue
This user is offline.
I agree, but I need the shot for transition purpose. If if was 1 second, that would be enough, but it is only 16 frames. I've extended it to the 30-32 frames (same length as the previous Tarkin shot). Looks much better now. Anyway, few more minor tweaks are needed for this scene.
Angel
This user is offline.
¤°•°•°•°•°•°•°•°•°¤Joshua_Blue said:
I agree, but I need the shot for transition purpose. If if was 1 second, that would be enough, but it is only 16 frames. I've extended it to the 30-32 frames (same length as the previous Tarkin shot). Looks much better now. Anyway, few more minor tweaks are needed for this scene.
Very nice video!
One thing that i would suggest is to make vader's movements slower when he says about the power of the force (aka like jaitea did) because he looks going up and down too fast.. He might be expresive as he talks behind a mask but after all he is a villain that can give you his point with minimum if not movement at all :)
-Angel
(♥Io♥)
Joshua_Blue
This user is offline.
I have not yet changed the video with the new slightly longer Tarkin shot. I'll post a new video, after I do the final touches.
The Aluminum Falcon
This user is offline.
Slayer of DeaditesJust saw the conference video. It looked good overall, though I agree about the oddly quick shot of Tarkin. I can't wait to see the slightly longer version. Your videos are really succeeding, in my opinion, in making Vader more ESB-esque.
doubleofive
This user is offline.
Chief Architect of Cynical MoralityFor some reason, I'd like to see that shot of Tarkin leaning back and some of the Vader shot switched. Have the guy talking to Tarkin, but show Vader's reaction, maybe cut out the guy looking up at Vader, and replace the extra space with Tarkin leaning back while Vader is talking... Hard to explain.
Star Wars Revisited Wordpress / Google+ / Facebook / Twitter
Cinetropolis - My new movie blog home
Where to hear me online
Joshua_Blue
This user is offline.
Here is the conference room video again: http://vimeo.com/31299002
The Tarkin shot which was too short is now longer. Some frames where I deleted Tarin speaking have been further cleaned up. I also made Vader's movements during his speech about the power of the force a bit slower. I will not be touching this segment now for some time, as after viewing it like a million times, I need a break from it.
darth_ender
This user is offline.
"darth endeor was a meanyhead" - FatherSkywalker, et al--QFTLooking good!
The ROTJ collaborative thread is a wealth of ideas, both on how to edit Return of the Jedi, as well as how to collaborate in an edit. Emanswfan has taken leadership of the project.
Password for all ROTJ-related clips: ROTJ
A very rough edit of how the Battle of Endor could go
A very rough idea of how ROTJ could end
Rough edit based on the final script with some deviation:
Part 1 Part 2 Part 3 Part 4
The Aluminum Falcon
This user is offline.
Slayer of DeaditesI like it! The longer shot of Tarkin works well. He seems uneasy but powerless to stop Vader. All in all, it's very good.
Joshua_Blue
This user is offline.
I've re-cut the scene aboard DS after Falcon lands and the crew is sent to scan the ship. The scanning guy no longer arbitrarily checks the non-equipment (looks like a small fire extinguisher), and the the whole scene is now a bit faster. I have always disliked the scene. We now immediately cut from the Han and the guys to the scanning crew climbing aboard the Falcon. Also a couple of smaller audio and video cuts to speed things up.
sketchrob
This user is offline.
The answer to 1984 is 1776I always thought it would have been cool in ANH, if when the blast doors close on Vader as the MF is taking off his saber plummets thru the doors ala Qui-Gon style and started toc ut a circle in them.
Joshua_Blue
This user is offline.
But it wouldn't make sense, because he was not worried about them getting away, as they have planted a tracking device on Falcon.
sketchrob
This user is offline.
The answer to 1984 is 1776It makes no more or less sense then throwing Tie Fighters at them or shooting at them while they leave.
Joshua_Blue
This user is offline.
Well, they had to put up at least some fight, so it wouldn't be so obvious they were tracking the Falcon ;)
Angel
This user is offline.
¤°•°•°•°•°•°•°•°•°¤sketchrob said:
I always thought it would have been cool in ANH, if when the blast doors close on Vader as the MF is taking off his saber plummets thru the doors ala Qui-Gon style and started toc ut a circle in them.
Nah just give him something more menacing ;)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8_lc8IlNi-o
-Angel
(♥Io♥)
ben_danger
This user is offline.
enthusiasti love how that scene closes on TFU.
imagine inserting a small shot after the falcon takes off, of vader in a similar manner. stormtroopers and staff running all over the place, but vader pausing and turning around at a much more menacing pace.
Joshua_Blue
This user is offline.
I'd love some more of Vader's show of force, but it is out of my scope... BTW, I love Vader in that TFU clip.
mrbenja0618
This user is offline.
"The greatest fraud ever perpetrated on the fanedit community." - Probably Anti-MatterI love that clip too... That game was ALMOST awesome. I will say all friggin' 5 minutes of the gameplay time they give you was pretty fun. =/
iamweasel
This user is offline.
JediWeasel
Hi,
First of all, great idea, IMHO a strong Vader is a great improvement to ANH. :)
I liked your videos, and I would like to make a suggestion, that (again IMHO) would make the choke scene perfect. Vader shouldn't release him in silence, it should say something like "Consider this a warning" or something like that. Of course, you will need to find the words in the movies and mount the phrase, but I believe that wouldn't be a problem. If you can't find it, you could try using that reading of the bible made by James Earl Jones. Luckily Vader has no mouth so he can say wherever you want. :)
Keep up the good work.
adywan
This user is offline.
"Untallented and clueless to the core"iamweasel said:
Hi,
First of all, great idea, IMHO a strong Vader is a great improvement to ANH. :)
I liked your videos, and I would like to make a suggestion, that (again IMHO) would make the choke scene perfect. Vader shouldn't release him in silence, it should say something like "Consider this a warning" or something like that. Of course, you will need to find the words in the movies and mount the phrase, but I believe that wouldn't be a problem. If you can't find it, you could try using that reading of the bible made by James Earl Jones. Luckily Vader has no mouth so he can say wherever you want. :)
Keep up the good work.
why not just move the line "i find you lack of faith disturbing" so he finishes this line right at the moment he releases him?
iamweasel
This user is offline.
JediWeaseladywan said:
why not just move the line "i find you lack of faith disturbing" so he finishes this line right at the moment he releases him?
Well, first I noticed it was unpolite of me not saying hi to everyone in this nice forum in my first message. Being an old star wars fan it is a shame I only joined this forum now.
Back to the topic, although I think it would be a improvement to move the line, I still believe it belongs where it is now, so it would be nice to have a new line where Vader warns about not doing that again. Anyway, just my 2 cents.
I would like to take the opportunity to thank you for taking the time to correct the Star Wars movies, I like everything you did in ANH:R. I like it so much that now I can't watch the original movies anymore, so I keep them here just to be legally allowed to have your Revisited version here. :)
Joshua_Blue
This user is offline.
I'm back now after a short break.
The choke scene will stay as it is for now, but I might revisit it.
Currently I am streamlining the fight aboard Tantive IV so the stromtroopers come off stronger and to improve the pace.
The Aluminum Falcon
This user is offline.
Slayer of DeaditesSounds interesting. It's cool you're daring to cut such iconic scenes. It'll be an intriguing fan edit.
Joshua_Blue
This user is offline.
Well, I personally never thought of the stormtroopers aboard Tantive as iconic, even as a child. Just clumsy.